General Discussion > Rants and Debate
RNA translation guides are better as tables than as wheels
Bri MT:
Hey fellow bio people and other interested parties!
As much as I feel like the radial ones should be quicker to read, I much prefer reading a codon table rather than using a wheel for translation. Made a quick poll which we can use to demonstrate which form is superior.
(This post is inspired by Coolmate's recent HSC challenging bio questions posting)
Owlbird83:
I'd never seen a codon wheel before (until I just googled then). They look so much easier to read than tables! And make more logical sense to me. (I like the colourfulness of some of the wheels too)
I'm not sure why every codon guide in textbooks/sacs/bio resources that I've come across all use the table, is it because pages are rectangles and they want angles to match up nicely?
Do you think you prefer the tables because you have been exposed to them more?
Coolmate:
--- Quote from: Bri MT on February 19, 2021, 09:41:31 pm ---Hey fellow bio people and other interested parties!
As much as I feel like the radial ones should be quicker to read, I much prefer reading a codon table rather than using a wheel for translation. Made a quick poll which we can use to demonstrate which form is superior.
(This post is inspired by Coolmate's recent HSC challenging bio questions posting)
--- End quote ---
I would definitely have to side with using a table, rather than a wheel. For me, it just makes more logical sense and easier to understand, but I know how to use both so I guess it's just preference.
--- Quote from: Owlbird83 on February 19, 2021, 09:50:09 pm ---I'm not sure why every codon guide in textbooks/sacs/bio resources that I've come across all use the table, is it because pages are rectangles and they want angles to match up nicely?
--- End quote ---
Probably, yeah this could be the reason
--- Quote from: Owlbird83 on February 19, 2021, 09:50:09 pm ---Do you think you prefer the tables because you have been exposed to them more?
--- End quote ---
I was first introduced to using tables, which I used for a while, then got introduced to the wheel one, so I guess I adapted (Bio pun not intended 8) ) most to using the table :)
Coolmate 8)
Bri MT:
--- Quote from: Owlbird83 on February 19, 2021, 09:50:09 pm ---I'd never seen a codon wheel before (until I just googled then). They look so much easier to read than tables! And make more logical sense to me. (I like the colourfulness of some of the wheels too)
I'm not sure why every codon guide in textbooks/sacs/bio resources that I've come across all use the table, is it because pages are rectangles and they want angles to match up nicely?
Do you think you prefer the tables because you have been exposed to them more?
--- End quote ---
It could be exposure but I think for me it's also about the uniformity of the table.
I've definitely come across tables more, maybe because they're easier to make?
K888:
Table definitely better than the wheel! Would be interested to see whether anyone actually prefers the wheel lol.
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
Go to full version