ATAR Notes: Forum
General Discussion => General Discussion Boards => News and Politics => Topic started by: EEEEEEP on July 25, 2017, 12:58:50 pm
-
http://www.abc.net.au/news/2017-07-24/sikh-family-challenge-christian-schools-turban-ban/8737716
"A Melbourne family has launched legal action against a Christian school for banning their son from wearing his traditional Sikh patka, a turban worn by children.
Sidhak Singh Arora, 5, was due to start prep at Melton Christian College, in Melbourne's north-west, this year.
But his patka does not comply with the school's uniform policy which prohibits students from wearing any type of religious head covering."
...........
Is this really just a case of a non issue? Students are required to adhere to policies.
Here is an Islamic school, women are expected to wear this.. which is okay as it is policy ... http://www.salamah.nsw.edu.au/wp-content/uploads/2016/09/A-Parents-Guide-to-School-Uniform.pdf
MCC, which is the school in question... http://mcc.vic.edu.au/content/MCC_Handbook_2017.pdf
"Head and/or face coverings that are related to faith-practices of faiths other than the Christian faith are not part of the Melton Christian College uniform so may not be worn to school."
**Islam school, islamic uniform. Christian school, Christian uniform **
Lastly SAME Issue, different schools.. In the name of equality... if it's dictated at an Islamic school and at a Christian school... then technically it is no issue.
These are both private religious schools which have their own values and such... so what's the issue here? They have their own right to set their own policies and rules.
-
http://www.abc.net.au/news/2017-07-24/sikh-family-challenge-christian-schools-turban-ban/8737716
"A Melbourne family has launched legal action against a Christian school for banning their son from wearing his traditional Sikh patka, a turban worn by children.
Sidhak Singh Arora, 5, was due to start prep at Melton Christian College, in Melbourne's north-west, this year.
But his patka does not comply with the school's uniform policy which prohibits students from wearing any type of religious head covering."
...........
Is this really just a case of a non issue? Students are required to adhere to policies.
Here is an Islamic school, women are expected to wear this.. which is okay as it is policy ... http://www.salamah.nsw.edu.au/wp-content/uploads/2016/09/A-Parents-Guide-to-School-Uniform.pdf
MCC, which is the school in question... http://mcc.vic.edu.au/content/MCC_Handbook_2017.pdf
"Head and/or face coverings that are related to faith-practices of faiths other than the Christian faith are not part of the Melton Christian College uniform so may not be worn to school."
**Islam school, islamic uniform. Christian school, Christian uniform **
Lastly SAME Issue, different schools.. In the name of equality... if it's dictated at an Islamic school and at a Christian school... then technically it is no issue.
These are both private religious schools which have their own values and such... so what's the issue here? They have their own right to set their own policies and rules.
If a school is able to take funding from a secular government then it absolutely should not be able to enforce draconian policies such as this. This is a clear cut case of discrimination and the fact that it's permissible under the law is a disgrace.
-
If a school is able to take funding from a secular government then it absolutely should not be able to enforce draconian policies such as this. This is a clear cut case of discrimination and the fact that it's permissible under the law is a disgrace.
Should the same apply for all schools? Christian, Jewish, Islamic etc?
-
If a school is able to take funding from a secular government then it absolutely should not be able to enforce draconian policies such as this. This is a clear cut case of discrimination and the fact that it's permissible under the law is a disgrace.
Thought it'd be relevant to share their 2015 Annual Report.
Pages 7, 8, and 9 on the PDF.
Edit: Wrong link. I was looking at a few different ones out of curiosity and managed to link the incorrect one. Vox Nihili provided the [URL=https://myschool.edu.au/SchoolProfile/Index/109550/MeltonChristianCollege/46303/2016tcorrect onet[/URL].
-
Thought it'd be relevant to share their 2015 Annual Report.
Pages 7, 8, and 9 on the PDF.
Over $15 million in grants...
If a school is able to take funding from a secular government then it absolutely should not be able to enforce draconian policies such as this. This is a clear cut case of discrimination and the fact that it's permissible under the law is a disgrace.
I want to contact Slydev and have him give me an "Admin +1" button that is worth 500 +1's, that is the extent to which I agree with this!
-
Thought it'd be relevant to share their 2015 Annual Report.
Pages 7, 8, and 9 on the PDF.
This is a different school. You can see the details of the finances of the one we're talking about here.
tl;dr nearly 75% of this school's funding came from the government.
Should the same apply for all schools? Christian, Jewish, Islamic etc?
Yes.