Administration => AN Community Lounge => Topic started by: Joseph41 on February 27, 2018, 02:22:37 pm
Title: ATAR Notes VCE/HSC Video Series SNEAK PEEK - and Feedback, Please!
Post by: Joseph41 on February 27, 2018, 02:22:37 pm
Heeeeere we go. I've managed to wrangle a sneak peek video for you for the upcoming revision video series. ;D Some things to say:
1. This definitely isn't finalised! This is just part of the way there, and we wanted to share with you our progress. ;) It's probably a bit unusual for that to happen but like, we figure we're making these videos for you, so there's literally nothing more valuable than your feedback! 2. We're going to be doing an HSC equivalent. So for all of you in New South Wales, please - your feedback is extra useful, because you'll be benefiting from it most! ;D
So, please enjoy, and let us know what you think! Is the lighting okay? Is the video too short/long? Were you distracted by the camera movements?
Title: Re: ATAR Notes VCE/HSC Video Series SNEAK PEEK - and Feedback, Please!
Post by: K888 on February 27, 2018, 02:28:21 pm
This looks soooooooooo good. Loving the filming - I always found it boring when a video only had one angle. I'm not sure whether you'll be doing this, but maybe intersperse the video with dot points of key info/a small summary? Otherwise it might be a bit of an info dump.
Title: Re: ATAR Notes VCE/HSC Video Series SNEAK PEEK - and Feedback, Please!
Post by: Joseph41 on February 27, 2018, 02:29:47 pm
This looks soooooooooo good. Loving the filming - I always found it boring when a video only had one angle. I'm not sure whether you'll be doing this, but maybe intersperse the video with dot points of key info/a small summary? Otherwise it might be a bit of an info dump.
Nice one! Thanks Kate. A lot of the videos will be interspersed with hand-writing (as you'd see in uni lectures etc.), because you're right - it could be a bit overwhelming otherwise! It just so happens that Karly didn't deem it necessary for this particular Business Management video. :)
Title: Re: ATAR Notes VCE/HSC Video Series SNEAK PEEK - and Feedback, Please!
Post by: AngelWings on February 27, 2018, 02:35:48 pm
Camera was a little shaky, which is slightly distracting. My recommendation is to perhaps avoid or have cleaner movements, if you can. Otherwise, it looks like a great start to something new!
EDIT: Also maybe a banner underneath Karly's face saying her name and the subject she's tutoring when she introduces herself, for those who miss it or are better readers than listeners. Might help in terms of professionalism or just being able to pinpoint the subject easier. :)
Title: Re: ATAR Notes VCE/HSC Video Series SNEAK PEEK - and Feedback, Please!
Post by: sdfg on February 27, 2018, 02:38:02 pm
Camera was a little shaky, which is slightly distracting. My recommendation is to perhaps avoid or have cleaner movements, if you can. Otherwise, it looks like a great start to something new!
Yeah, agreed - camera was a bit shaky which made it slightly distracting. Otherwise, looks super cool and awesome! ;D
Title: Re: ATAR Notes VCE/HSC Video Series SNEAK PEEK - and Feedback, Please!
Post by: Joseph41 on February 27, 2018, 02:39:29 pm
Camera was a little shaky, which is slightly distracting. My recommendation is to perhaps avoid or have cleaner movements, if you can. Otherwise, it looks like a great start to something new!
EDIT: Also maybe a banner underneath Karly's face saying her name and the subject she's tutoring when she introduces herself, for those who miss it or are better readers than listeners. Might help in terms of professionalism or just being able to pinpoint the subject easier. :)
Yeah, 100%! Titles and stuff are definitely coming. :)
Title: Re: ATAR Notes VCE/HSC Video Series SNEAK PEEK - and Feedback, Please!
Post by: Poet on February 27, 2018, 04:37:20 pm
EDIT: Also maybe a banner underneath Karly's face saying her name and the subject she's tutoring when she introduces herself, for those who miss it or are better readers than listeners. Might help in terms of professionalism or just being able to pinpoint the subject easier. :)
This is great! I'm so excited to see what y'all come up with. And I agree with AngelWings' opinion on the title for readers as well as listeners. Will you be writing down key points the tutors make at the bottom of the video as well, (short statements that really stand out) just to keep people on track? This could be helpful.
Title: Re: ATAR Notes VCE/HSC Video Series SNEAK PEEK - and Feedback, Please!
Post by: Joseph41 on February 27, 2018, 04:47:10 pm
This is great! I'm so excited to see what y'all come up with. And I agree with AngelWings' opinion on the title for readers as well as listeners. Will you be writing down key points the tutors make at the bottom of the video as well, (short statements that really stand out) just to keep people on track? This could be helpful.
Titles will definitely be a thing. :)
Good suggestion on the other captions and the like - this is probably something for us to consider for the HSC series. :D
Title: Re: ATAR Notes VCE/HSC Video Series SNEAK PEEK - and Feedback, Please!
Post by: beatroot on February 27, 2018, 10:01:44 pm
Hey!
I'm a film student so I'm just going to comment on the technical aspects aha. Some of them have been addressed above-
- Stick with one camera angle. The cuts were a bit out of place imo and were unnecessary. Plus only having one angle will make it easier to edit in post-prod ;) Though if you do want to have multiple shots, please don't have the camera shaking- which brings me to my next point. - Camera was shaky and made me dizzy and distracted. Having a tripod is definitely worth it ;D Or a stabiliser at least (you can have an actual, physical stabiliser or edit the video to be stabilise in post prod) - Captions please - This is just a suggestion but have text pop on the screen for the key words mentioned in the video. Anna Akana (on youtube) does this in her videos and I find it really engaging
The lighting, camera quality and sound is absolutely perfect! May I ask what lights, camera and microphone did you use? This video series looks really good! Can't wait for this (despite already graduating the HSC ahah). This would be heaps useful and helpful!!
Title: Re: ATAR Notes VCE/HSC Video Series SNEAK PEEK - and Feedback, Please!
Post by: Joseph41 on February 28, 2018, 11:15:06 am
^Thanks Bea! :D
I think the movements were actually intentional to try to make the whole thing a bit more natural or organic or whatever, but I think I agree: it's distracting!
I'm going to let our filming/editing team know, and get them to fix it up in post-prod. :)
Title: Re: ATAR Notes VCE/HSC Video Series SNEAK PEEK - and Feedback, Please!
Post by: EEEEEEP on February 28, 2018, 12:21:43 pm
Yeah.... the motion thingy made me sick (esp when viewing on a full screen, 23 inch monitor)...
Also I found the video doesn't capture the eye. Not sure if it's just me..but I'm not a very big fan of just talking. There needs to be some: - Music - Text - Animation
Title: Re: ATAR Notes VCE/HSC Video Series SNEAK PEEK - and Feedback, Please!
Post by: Joseph41 on February 28, 2018, 04:23:26 pm
Yeah.... the motion thingy made me sick (esp when viewing on a full screen, 23 inch monitor)...
Also I found the video doesn't capture the eye. Not sure if it's just me..but I'm not a very big fan of just talking. There needs to be some: - Music - Text - Animation
Thanks EEEEEEP! ;D
Title: Re: ATAR Notes VCE/HSC Video Series SNEAK PEEK - and Feedback, Please!
Post by: Joseph41 on March 15, 2018, 09:34:57 am
Hey all! So we have a bit of an update. Do you think this is better? Do you think it's worse?
Titles and the like are still to come. And there's a bit of weird stuff going on around the edges - just ignore that for now. ;D
Looking forward to your thoughts.
Title: Re: ATAR Notes VCE/HSC Video Series SNEAK PEEK - and Feedback, Please!
Post by: PhoenixxFire on March 15, 2018, 05:47:36 pm
I think it’s better :)
I know someone said it earlier but the shots from the side feel unnecessary, if you’re planning on making longer videos and don’t want them just straight on I would prefer it changing to a screen with writing/images with her talking over the top of it. With a video that is only a few minutes long the angle changes are just distracting.
Title: Re: ATAR Notes VCE/HSC Video Series SNEAK PEEK - and Feedback, Please!
Post by: Joseph41 on March 19, 2018, 10:57:21 am
Thanks PF. :)
Title: Re: ATAR Notes VCE/HSC Video Series SNEAK PEEK - and Feedback, Please!
Post by: EEEEEEP on March 19, 2018, 11:10:41 am
Hey all! So we have a bit of an update. Do you think this is better? Do you think it's worse?
Titles and the like are still to come. And there's a bit of weird stuff going on around the edges - just ignore that for now. ;D
Looking forward to your thoughts.
That side shot is still giving me troubles. I hate how the camera goes around her, but at the same time... the camera is not steady.
The side shots still makes me dizzy :(. Not a fan of that shot at all, I'm afraid.
Title: Re: ATAR Notes VCE/HSC Video Series SNEAK PEEK - and Feedback, Please!
Post by: beatroot on March 19, 2018, 02:53:30 pm
^ I agree with PF and E6P. The side shots are unnecessary, distracting and makes me feel a bit dizzy. If you reeallly want the side shots, just have the camera steady of a tripod rather than having the camera circling around her. It'll be less distracting I reckon. Though I do like how the front shots are now stabilised :)
Title: Re: ATAR Notes VCE/HSC Video Series SNEAK PEEK - and Feedback, Please!
Post by: jamonwindeyer on March 19, 2018, 07:50:14 pm
I feel like I'm in the minority because I like the side shots! Though maybe, now it's been mentioned, I'd like them more if they were stabilised?
Am keen to see it with titles :)
Title: Re: ATAR Notes VCE/HSC Video Series SNEAK PEEK - and Feedback, Please!
Post by: Joseph41 on April 19, 2018, 12:42:57 pm
So, I have all of the videos up on YouTube (private) - music/titles etc. included.
Anybody want to see a couple? :)
Title: Re: ATAR Notes VCE/HSC Video Series SNEAK PEEK - and Feedback, Please!
Post by: beatroot on April 19, 2018, 01:55:12 pm
So, I have all of the videos up on YouTube (private) - music/titles etc. included.
Anybody want to see a couple? :)
Yes please :)
Title: Re: ATAR Notes VCE/HSC Video Series SNEAK PEEK - and Feedback, Please!
Post by: Joseph41 on April 19, 2018, 02:45:17 pm
Will just note here that we had multiple discussions about all feedback provided in this thread, and we'll be implementing a lot of it for the HSC videos. :)
A few quick samples of the 120 videos, literally just randomly selected from the total pool haha:
Physics (Alevine):
Methods (Luke):
Biology (Katherine):
Title: Re: ATAR Notes VCE/HSC Video Series SNEAK PEEK - and Feedback, Please!
Post by: Poet on April 19, 2018, 04:55:43 pm
Will just note here that we had multiple discussions about all feedback provided in this thread, and we'll be implementing a lot of it for the HSC videos. :)
Hey, J41! Love the implementation of the name banners, and the movement in the videos is a lot less exaggerated (and therefore no longer distracting). You guys have done really well solving some of the original hiccups; I'm excited to see more than just tasters! ^-^
Title: Re: ATAR Notes VCE/HSC Video Series SNEAK PEEK - and Feedback, Please!
Post by: Joseph41 on April 19, 2018, 05:06:34 pm
Hey, J41! Love the implementation of the name banners, and the movement in the videos is a lot less exaggerated (and therefore no longer distracting). You guys have done really well solving some of the original hiccups; I'm excited to see more than just tasters! ^-^
Thanks so much for this! :)
Title: Re: ATAR Notes VCE/HSC Video Series SNEAK PEEK - and Feedback, Please!
Post by: Joseph41 on May 16, 2018, 11:23:14 am
We're getting veeerrrryyyyyryryryyy close to release!
EDIT: Like, potentially today close. I'll make sure y'all are first to know. ;D