ATAR Notes: Forum

National Education => Admissions tests => Selective Schools Admissions Tests => Topic started by: m.yara184 on August 27, 2019, 09:41:13 pm

Title: Disappointed with result
Post by: m.yara184 on August 27, 2019, 09:41:13 pm
Maths: Superior
Numerical: Superior
Writing: Superior
Reading: High
Verbal: Average
All I got was a pd to mhs, but I got a rejection, so I didn’t make it to the interview, and I got a first round to Nossal. Meanwhile there’s my friend with 2 sups made it to mhs first round and he’s at the same school as me!!!!!!!!! CAN SOMEONE EXPLAIN WHY

Mod edit (VN): changed title.
Title: Re: WTF I JUST GOT MY RESULTS, DIDNT MAKE IT TO MHS WITH 3 SUPERIORS!!??
Post by: ProbotMelbourne on August 27, 2019, 09:42:48 pm
Maths: Superior
Numerical: Superior
Writing: Superior
Reading: High
Verbal: Average
All I got was a pd to mhs, but I got a rejection, so I didn’t make it to the interview, and I got a first round to Nossal. Meanwhile there’s my friend with 2 sups made it to mhs first round and he’s at the same school as me!!!!!!!!! CAN SOMEONE EXPLAIN WHY
I knew you’d do good but anyways, I think u did like really bad in verbal(probs in the low half of average) cause I can’t find any other reason. Anyways, good luck with whatever school you’re going.(I’m no name)
Title: Re: WTF I JUST GOT MY RESULTS, DIDNT MAKE IT TO MHS WITH 3 SUPERIORS!!??
Post by: m.yara184 on August 27, 2019, 09:44:20 pm
I knew you’d do good but anyways, I think u did like really bad in verbal(probs in the low half of average) cause I can’t find any other reason. Anyways, good luck with whatever school you’re going.(I’m no name)
Yeah that’s probably why lol. Verbal fucked me up sm (excuse my language)
Title: Re: WTF I JUST GOT MY RESULTS, DIDNT MAKE IT TO MHS WITH 3 SUPERIORS!!??
Post by: 830cracker on August 27, 2019, 09:49:12 pm
It’s okay, congrats for getting a superior on numerical. I only got an above average even I did like 30 questions, so this shows that u never knows what the results’ going to be, which means that u would be likely getting a late offer.
Title: Re: WTF I JUST GOT MY RESULTS, DIDNT MAKE IT TO MHS WITH 3 SUPERIORS!!??
Post by: m.yara184 on August 27, 2019, 09:55:52 pm
It’s okay, congrats for getting a superior on numerical. I only got an above average even I did like 30 questions, so this shows that u never knows what the results’ going to be, which means that u would be likely getting a late offer.
Thanks and congrats on getting a superior on verbal, I got an average on it eeeeee. This whole system ur rigged anyways. What was ur first preference?
Title: Re: Disappointed with result
Post by: Sally Zhong on August 27, 2019, 09:57:26 pm
u prob in a good school and just didn't make quota. Did u have yr interview?
Title: Re: WTF I JUST GOT MY RESULTS, DIDNT MAKE IT TO MHS WITH 3 SUPERIORS!!??
Post by: colline on August 27, 2019, 10:02:13 pm
The reason is because the results you get, ‘superior’ ‘high average’ etc are only RANGES that contain your actual score. Your three superiors could have been borderline ‘high average’, while your friend’s two may be on the higher end of the superior range. Your friend may have still gotten a higher total score than you, despite the results you’re told which seemingly suggest otherwise.

But please keep in mind, the select entry test doesn’t mean that much in the long run and doesn’t limit your performance in VCE at all. If you are truly a gifted student, then you would do well in VCE regardless of your cohort.

Btw if it offers any comfort, back when I did the test I got four superiors and still got rejected from Macrob, Nossal, AND Cory. Seemed like the end of the world back then, but now I couldn’t care less. ;D
Title: Re: Disappointed with result
Post by: m.yara184 on August 27, 2019, 10:02:35 pm
u prob in a good school and just didn't make quota. Did u have yr interview?
No didn’t make it to the Interview
Title: Re: WTF I JUST GOT MY RESULTS, DIDNT MAKE IT TO MHS WITH 3 SUPERIORS!!??
Post by: 830cracker on August 27, 2019, 10:12:03 pm
Thanks and congrats on getting a superior on verbal, I got an average on it eeeeee. This whole system ur rigged anyways. What was ur first preference?

Thanks and yes ikr, like I don’t know how ppl get superiors for reading even I got an average when I felt like I did like my second well subject lol. Don’t too much about that average as I’m pretty sure that most ppl in my school who got into mhs get averages as well. As u accepted the offer from nossal, u should kept a spot for mhs late offer as the 5% rule still applies for late offers(sorry if I didn’t explained this well like I just want to say that u really do have a high chance for getting one) :)

I applied for nossal as first pref, then macrob and Cory. My school is really competitive as well like it reached the 5% and there’s 7 more ppl who got a pd
Title: Re: WTF I JUST GOT MY RESULTS, DIDNT MAKE IT TO MHS WITH 3 SUPERIORS!!??
Post by: m.yara184 on August 27, 2019, 10:13:50 pm
Thanks and yes ikr, like I don’t know how ppl get superiors for reading even I got an average when I felt like I did like my second well subject lol. Don’t too much about that average as I’m pretty sure that most ppl in my school who got into mhs get averages as well. As u accepted the offer from nossal, u should kept a spot for mhs late offer as the 5% rule still applies for late offers(sorry if I didn’t explained this well like I just want to say that u really do have a high chance for getting one) :)

I applied for nossal as first pref, then macrob and Cory. My school is really competitive as well like it reached the 5% and there’s 7 more ppl who got a pd
Oh no there is still a spot for late offers. I called the selective entry unit they said that by accepting nossal, it does not affect my mhs 2nd round offer chance.
Title: Re: Disappointed with result
Post by: Louis23 on August 27, 2019, 10:16:17 pm
830 cracker what were ur scores?
Title: Re: WTF I JUST GOT MY RESULTS, DIDNT MAKE IT TO MHS WITH 3 SUPERIORS!!??
Post by: zuijinde on August 27, 2019, 10:30:32 pm
The reason is because the results you get, ‘superior’ ‘high average’ etc are only RANGES that contain your actual score. Your three superiors could have been borderline ‘high average’, while your friend’s two may be on the higher end of the superior range. Your friend may have still gotten a higher total score than you, despite the results you’re told which seemingly suggest otherwise.
All this is true.

Your average may have dragged you down a bit, and also assuming that your school is competitive, this would have drastically affected that. MHS is highly competitive and they tend to look at scores that are favourable from competitive schools. Although, I will say it is a bit strange to not have received PD.

To put in perspective, I got into MHS and didn't even get any superiors back in 2014, but the ranking of my school was relatively low which got me entry.
Title: Re: WTF I JUST GOT MY RESULTS, DIDNT MAKE IT TO MHS WITH 3 SUPERIORS!!??
Post by: m.yara184 on August 27, 2019, 10:35:02 pm
All this is true.

Your average may have dragged you down a bit, and also assuming that your school is competitive, this would have drastically affected that. MHS is highly competitive and they tend to look at scores that are favourable from competitive schools. Although, I will say it is a bit strange to not have received PD.

To put in perspective, I got into MHS and didn't even get any superiors back in 2014, but the ranking of my school was relatively low which got me entry.
I did get a pd, but I didn’t make it to the interview stage
Title: Re: WTF I JUST GOT MY RESULTS, DIDNT MAKE IT TO MHS WITH 3 SUPERIORS!!??
Post by: zuijinde on August 27, 2019, 10:40:14 pm
I did get a pd, but I didn’t make it to the interview stage
My apologies, didn't read it right. Perhaps your folio of achievements weren't up to par with their standards? It was kinda joked that MHS was very pedantic about these things.
Title: Re: WTF I JUST GOT MY RESULTS, DIDNT MAKE IT TO MHS WITH 3 SUPERIORS!!??
Post by: 830cracker on August 27, 2019, 10:45:08 pm
Oh no there is still a spot for late offers. I called the selective entry unit they said that by accepting nossal, it does not affect my mhs 2nd round offer chance.

Yep that’s what I’m saying. Like what I mean is that u would only get a late offer if you accepted the offer from nossal, as if u don’t then other people from you school might took over your spot(for example, someone from ur school can be closer to the cut line for nossal than u did to mhs, and they might took over ur spot if u decline the offer for nossal, and then ur highly unlikely to get an offer for mhs as the 5% rule applies)

So what I’m initially meaning is that u really do have a higher chance for getting into mhs after u accepted the offer from nossal, as there would be no chance if u declined that offer and the 5% rule in ur school applies :)
Title: Re: Disappointed with result
Post by: 830cracker on August 27, 2019, 10:48:23 pm
830 cracker what were ur scores?

Ohh i got:

Verbal-superior
Numerical- above ave
Reading- ave
Math - high ave
Writing- ave

It is not as bad as I thought-_-

What’s ur scores(if ur fine with saying) :)
Title: Re: Disappointed with result
Post by: indigoblu on August 27, 2019, 10:55:42 pm
It's okay to not get in the first time and my friend didn't pass either. She cried over a few days, didn't want to go back to school, but then she got back up and realised there were many chances in the future and she was good at science.
Title: Re: Disappointed with result
Post by: Mysteriousplayer05_YT on August 27, 2019, 10:56:12 pm
I got
Numerical- Superior
Maths- Superior
Verbal- above
Reading- high
Writing- high
I still can’t believe that I actually made it in SCHS with these results :on
Title: Re: Disappointed with result
Post by: Stormbreaker-X on August 28, 2019, 02:29:17 pm
I just found out that i got a higher score than my friend, and he got into his first preference (MHS). I didn't even get a PD, but I got a late offer to my second preference, schs, 10 days ago. I don't understand why, and is it still possible to get an offer to my first pref?
The selection process isn't fair, I heard of people with 3-4 superiors and not getting into one.
Title: Re: Disappointed with result
Post by: XxLOSTYxX on August 28, 2019, 02:41:42 pm
It's okay to not get in the first time and my friend didn't pass either. She cried over a few days, didn't want to go back to school, but then she got back up and realised there were many chances in the future and she was good at science.

Tell her to not lose hope, there are still lots of opportunities:
MacRob, John Monash Science School, Suzanne Cory and Nossal High year 10 entry
MacRob, John Monash Science School, Elizabeth Blackburn of Sciences and Nossal year 11 entry
Elizabeth Blackburn of Sciences year 12 entry
Title: Re: Disappointed with result
Post by: Stormbreaker-X on August 28, 2019, 02:50:34 pm
Tell her to not lose hope, there are still lots of opportunities:
MacRob, John Monash Science School, Suzanne Cory and Nossal High year 10 entry
MacRob, John Monash Science School, Elizabeth Blackburn of Sciences and Nossal year 11 entry
Elizabeth Blackburn of Sciences year 12 entry
That was me for Ebs xD, I was so let down. But back when I was in year 8, I was like whatever.
Title: Re: Disappointed with result
Post by: Louis23 on August 28, 2019, 05:22:12 pm
Ohh i got:

Verbal-superior
Numerical- above ave
Reading- ave
Math - high ave
Writing- ave

It is not as bad as I thought-_-

What’s ur scores(if ur fine with saying) :)


My scores were the same just different scores for different subject did you get in to any school
Title: Re: Disappointed with result
Post by: rakshanaraj06 on August 28, 2019, 05:41:36 pm
my friend literally got into macrob 2nd round offer with just 1 sup. like wtf
Title: Re: Disappointed with result
Post by: AMC for life on August 29, 2019, 08:19:28 am
Hey people
I got
A high average in V.R
A above average in N.R
A above average in R.C
A average in mathematics
A high average in writing
Do I have any chance??
And what did you guys get???
Title: Re: Disappointed with result
Post by: Stormbreaker-X on August 29, 2019, 08:38:36 am
Hey people
I got
A high average in V.R
A above average in N.R
A above average in R.C
A average in mathematics
A high average in writing
Do I have any chance??
And what did you guys get???
You might get a chance if some people reject the offer.
Title: Re: Disappointed with result
Post by: Weirdobtsarmy on August 29, 2019, 09:00:08 am
my friend literally got into macrob 2nd round offer with just 1 sup. like wtf
Lol that’s me :(
I’m just dumb my dude
Title: Re: Disappointed with result
Post by: MAN0033 on October 06, 2019, 06:27:05 pm
Will I get a late offer with 2 superiors, 1 above and 2 highs
Title: Re: WTF I JUST GOT MY RESULTS, DIDNT MAKE IT TO MHS WITH 3 SUPERIORS!!??
Post by: CHA0021 on October 31, 2019, 11:07:05 pm
All this is true.

Your average may have dragged you down a bit, and also assuming that your school is competitive, this would have drastically affected that. MHS is highly competitive and they tend to look at scores that are favourable from competitive schools. Although, I will say it is a bit strange to not have received PD.

To put in perspective, I got into MHS and didn't even get any superiors back in 2014, but the ranking of my school was relatively low which got me entry.

what were ur actual results