ATAR Notes: Forum

HSC Stuff => HSC Subjects + Help => HSC Marking and Feedback => Topic started by: minh.tran278 on January 21, 2020, 11:12:00 pm

Title: Billy Elliot Thesis
Post by: minh.tran278 on January 21, 2020, 11:12:00 pm
Hi, this is my intro thanks to Angelina's suggestions to the question "In what way does your prescribed text (Billy Elliot) offer new insights into the anomalies in human behaviour and motivations". Could anyone please give me some comments on this?

"The film Billy Elliot by Stephen Daldry adopts the depiction of Billy and Michael as anomalous factors to demonstrate new understandings of what drives human actions. From here, audiences come to realise the valuable outcomes gained from the refusal to conform to societal norms. Through the study of Billy Elliot, audiences are exposed to deviant behaviours in the identity of Michael and Billy, their rejection of social expectations and the relationships they form along their journey."

pink= "in what way" part of the question
purple= "offer new insights" part of the question
Title: Re: Billy Elliot Thesis
Post by: angewina_naguen on January 22, 2020, 12:25:22 pm
Hi, this is my intro thanks to Angelina's suggestions to the question "In what way does your prescribed text (Billy Elliot) offer new insights into the anomalies in human behaviour and motivations". Could anyone please give me some comments on this?

"The film Billy Elliot by Stephen Daldry adopts the depiction of Billy and Michael as anomalous factors to demonstrate new understandings of what drives human actions. From here, audiences come to realise the valuable outcomes gained from the refusal to conform to societal norms. Through the study of Billy Elliot, audiences are exposed to deviant behaviours in the identity of Michael and Billy, their rejection of social expectations and the relationships they form along their journey."

pink= "in what way" part of the question
purple= "offer new insights" part of the question

Hey, minh.tran278!

Great to see you've given the question a shot! I've provided some comments below which I hope might help  :)

Thesis Feedback
The film Billy Elliot by Stephen Daldry adopts the depiction of Billy and Michael as anomalous factors (You could even be more general here and dive into the character examples you'll be using later in the bodies. Something along the lines of "Through the depiction of anomalous characters, texts explore human motivations and behaviours..." and continue from there?) to demonstrate new understandings of what drives human actions. From here, audiences come to realise the valuable outcomes (And experiences maybe?)gained from the refusal to conform to societal norms  (Perhaps simplify this to just "challenging societal norms" rather than "the refusal to conform"?). Through the study of Stephen Daldry's film  (I would introduce the text here, rather than in the first sentence) Billy Elliot, audiences are exposed to deviant behaviours in the identity of Michael and Billy, their rejection of social expectations and the relationships they form along their journey. (This last sentence is great! It summarises the judgement you have made in the thesis well and brings a natural point of segue into the next section. Well done!)

Angelina  ;D