Can everyone just be a little less picky? I hate it when people are picky, it's one of the bad side-effects of being too politically correct sometimes, that we can't just accept that sometimes people say things which can be read as mean, but had no such intention.
I think this is the case here, Florian's just saying something that's pretty rational, that it's stupid to copy something from another source and not understand it and he was probably having a bit of a joke with the "winning" stuff - there was nothing he said that was really even that bad.
Stick - I think you're reading into what Florian did too much, he merely stated what he believed - he never called anyone else stupid, he called their actions stupid and he backed up why he felt that way, I found that was quite rational. He really didn't do anything to warrant a discussion on his motives and actions. I'm sure you've called other people's actions stupid before - I know I have, if somebody did something stupid, I would say "why would you do that, it's stupid" or "that was such a stupid thing to do" - there's nothing wrong with such remarks.
Maybe we should just stop being so picky, generally when people say something that appears mean, they don't mean it that way at all, so don't read into it so much. Most importantly, be resilient and don't take offence, the more offended you are by things, the more difficult your life will be.
Anyways, yeah, let's get back to chemistry as Laseredd says.