Login

Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.

December 09, 2025, 05:45:13 pm

Author Topic: Essay Marking for the Selective School Exam  (Read 65981 times)  Share 

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

ProbotMelbourne

  • Forum Obsessive
  • ***
  • Posts: 210
  • Respect: 0
Re: Essay Marking for the Selective School Exam
« Reply #105 on: January 13, 2019, 11:40:08 pm »
0
Topic:Should homework be banned?

Many people argue that homework should be banned, although, is it necessary? The word homework alone evokes many negative and positive connotations by students and teachers. (nice!) Homework should not be banned as it is a great way to develop responsibilities and be punctual (ok... in what way?). It also makes a student become more intelligent (how do you know?). It also connects families together(weak argument). ??? how does it connect families together?

Homework is a great way to develop responsibilities and be punctual. Many children who get homework usually hand it in time Nope. Bad argument.. This becomes a for the student and the student (don't repeat the same noun again) becomes punctual for every responsibility they get. For example, if a student gets a chore assigned to them by their parents, such as cleaning the dishes, they mostly complete it in time as they are used to having responsibilities and being punctual. This highlights why homework should not be banned. Honestly, pretty weak. How does homework make you more responsible? In fact, in this day and age, I'd probably argue that it's make people less responsible and punctual)

In addition, a student becomes more intelligent if they do homework. There is a saying,’practice makes perfect.’ (nope, 'practise makes perfect' is a rubbish saying. If you practise the wrong thing over and over, then you end up being perfect at being incorrect
Some students find it hard to catch up in class, so they do homework at home. (ok...) They keep practising their homework at home and soon become perfect. Homework makes the student study more which makes they will become more clever. If students are already ahead in class, the teachers can give them advanced homework which increases their knowledge. This indicates why homework should not be banned.your linking is not good

Finally, homework also connects families.Many students are not able to connect with their families because everyone is busy. With homework, the student can ask help from their parents, which also makes some bonding time. This exemplifies why homework should not be banned, who are your intended audience? i don't think my parents know anything about specialist maths. You literally had the same linking sentences as your previous paragraph, but replaced the 'indicates' with 'exemplifies'. Not a good look

Many people argue that homework wastes time. However, many people have time to play video games and play outside,so why cannot they do their homework.(RAN OUT OF TIME FOR REBUTTAL CONCLUDING SENTENCE,I couldn’t even think of one)

To conclude, homework should not be banned. It is a great way for a student to develop responsibilities and become punctual. It also increases the knowledge of a student. It even creates some bonding between families. Now let us stand up and say yes to homework. extremely cliche

Honestly, I really think you should be working on the harder topics. The topics you've done are what I expect from yr5-yr7 Naplan. Bear in mind that the selective exams aren't this easy.

Lol,yeah I agree with you.I was searching up random topics and i found “homework should be banned” so I did that cause it sounded super easy.
That’s what my teacher said lol,practice makes perfect is a bad saying as If someone practices the wrong thing.He said”Perfect practice makes perfect”.😂
Btw,I either get mucked up topics like ‘Sloths aren’t lazy,they are saving their energy.That energy is released today’ and ‘Last time I danced with death,I stepped on its toes’ and sometimes I get easy topics like ‘homework should be banned’ and ‘The beach’ lol.

For the family one,my intended audience were children,from year 1-year 12.Some parents are tutors and their kids can ask them for help.

My linking sentences are HORRIBLE,need help with them
4% battery,going to go off.
Thanks for marking my essays,bye!!

Wait,how does hw make kids less punctual.They make them punctual.If a kid gets hw everyday and hands them in,it becomes a habit to do everything on time(I exaggerate ALOT,maybe not).

Wait,your name is godnifty?Thought it was NiftyGOD

ProbotMelbourne

  • Forum Obsessive
  • ***
  • Posts: 210
  • Respect: 0
Re: Essay Marking for the Selective School Exam
« Reply #106 on: January 14, 2019, 12:02:45 am »
0
'Wait,how does hw make kids less punctual.They make them punctual.If a kid gets hw everyday and hands them in,it becomes a habit to do everything on time(I exaggerate ALOT,maybe not).'
Everyone here at mhs got hw in yr 9 pretty much everyday, and you really think anyone actually handed them in ON time/at all? I know for sure that it became a habit for me to dodge hw instead of doing it :P

I get what you're saying, but you have to look at the bigger picture.

1% battery rn,I get what you’re saying.I get hw like once a month and I do it lol,if I get hw every day,I’d never do it.It would make me want to skip hw lol,I agree with you.

ProbotMelbourne

  • Forum Obsessive
  • ***
  • Posts: 210
  • Respect: 0
Re: Essay Marking for the Selective School Exam
« Reply #107 on: January 14, 2019, 10:31:08 am »
0
Decent essay, but still you do not elaborate on your points and ideas. Some of your points are also illogical and irrelevant to the topic. You should use common sense for your points too.
Keep the good work up!

Thanks!
I probably should take some time to think better arguments.I take like 30 seconds to think of 2-3 arguments so I have more time to write but I don’t think it’s working.I should maybe write a plan down(1 min).Whenever I look at the topic,i Use the first argument that pops up in my brain.I used the weak argument cause I couldn’t think of any other arguments😐
I’ll probably write a creative which is more descriptive and evolves around one scene.

ProbotMelbourne

  • Forum Obsessive
  • ***
  • Posts: 210
  • Respect: 0
Re: Essay Marking for the Selective School Exam
« Reply #108 on: January 14, 2019, 10:48:02 am »
0
That's ok! I advise you not to write 15 minutes essay as of now but instead, take however long it would to create a more meticulous and not rushed essay with less errors and then work on your time.

Ok,I’ll try that from now on.Thanks for the tip

ProbotMelbourne

  • Forum Obsessive
  • ***
  • Posts: 210
  • Respect: 0
Re: Essay Marking for the Selective School Exam
« Reply #109 on: January 14, 2019, 12:07:57 pm »
0
I’m probably going to write an essay tonight ;D

The Progenitor

  • Trailblazer
  • *
  • Posts: 40
  • Respect: 0
Re: Essay Marking for the Selective School Exam
« Reply #110 on: January 14, 2019, 01:07:54 pm »
0
Wrote another essay, again on paper. Took roughly 20-22 minutes to write on paper, but I had to copy it onto this forum. Any feedback would be recommended, especially regarding selective school exams.
-
The topic is Social media brings about social, political and environmental change. Discuss.
-
Social media plays an important role in many peoples lives. Social media networks like Twitter, Instagram and Facebook have reached new levels of communication convenience. However this isn't all, social media also brings about political, social and environmental changes too.

The addition of social media has increased connectiveness like never seen before. It is a space to share information, research and warnings, as well as marketing many things globally with the click of a button. On the other hand, the social changes of social media have also created mass cyber-bullying and feelings of inadequacy. The increased connectivity that social media has introduced creates more online harassers which verbally abuse social media users. Furthermore, the increased connectivity also allows celebrities and models profiles and pictures to be accessed by anyone, anywhere, creating feelings of self-loathing and inadequacy regarding ones own body.

Similarly, social media has also brought about several beneficial political changes. Now being a platform for goals and politicians to access the public and vice versa. However, there is a big shift in power to share information which can lead towards national security breaches, recruiting terrorists, Wikileaks, all of which are near impossible to prevent and pose a serious threat towards public safety and national security.

Furthermore, social media also indirectly affects the environment around us, now (due to the creation of social media) people can receive information nearly instantly on man-made or natural disasters and act as a global community. This means many countries can arrange contributions towards disaster relief. But, the increased attention to many sensitive and sacred areas from social media exposure, increasingly ruins and destroys these important areas from excessive and overwhelming tourism.

Social media certainly provides many social, environmental and political changes. Given this, it is more important than ever before for us to be aware of the benefits and negatives to social media.

Thanks for reading, looking forward to writing more essays to post on this forum.

Also, I am happy to mark essays as I feel like its a great way for me to improve my own writing too.

The Progenitor

  • Trailblazer
  • *
  • Posts: 40
  • Respect: 0
Re: Essay Marking for the Selective School Exam
« Reply #111 on: January 14, 2019, 02:56:20 pm »
0
Advice taken onboard, thanks for the feedback.

ProbotMelbourne

  • Forum Obsessive
  • ***
  • Posts: 210
  • Respect: 0
Re: Essay Marking for the Selective School Exam
« Reply #112 on: January 14, 2019, 03:05:16 pm »
0
Wrote another essay, again on paper. Took roughly 20-22 minutes to write on paper, but I had to copy it onto this forum. Any feedback would be recommended, especially regarding selective school exams.
-
The topic is Social media brings about social, political and environmental change. Discuss.
-
Social media plays an important role in many peoples lives. Social media networks like Twitter, Instagram and Facebook have reached new levels of communication convenience. However this isn't all, social media also brings about political, social and environmental changes too.INTRO NEEDS A BIT MORE DETAIL

The addition of social media has increased connectiveness like never seen before. It is a space to share information, research and warnings, as well as marketing many things globally with the click of a button.”click of a button...nice On the other hand, the social changes of social media have also created mass cyber-bullying and feelings of inadequacywhat does inadequacy mean?lol. The increased connectivity that social media has introduced creates more online harassers which verbally abuse social media users. Furthermore, the increased connectivity also allows celebrities and models profiles and pictures to be accessed by anyone, anywhere, creating feelings of self-loathing and inadequacy regarding ones own body.i like it Your argument is great.Sorry I’m new to marking and im not doing that good.FORGOT Linking tho

Similarly, social media has also brought about several beneficial political changes. Now being a platform for goals and politicians to access the public and vice versa. However, there is a big shift in power to share information which can lead towards national security breaches, recruiting terrorists, Wikileaks, all of which are near impossible to prevent and pose a serious threat towards public safety and national security.Again?No linking sentence,your grammar is decent tho.Couldve added more info.i think the argument is OK

Furthermore, social media also indirectly affects the environment around us, now (due to the creation of social media) people can receive information nearly instantly on man-made or natural disasters and act as a global community. This means many countries can arrange contributions towards disaster relief. But, the increased attention to many sensitive and sacred areas from social media exposure, increasingly ruins and destroys these important areas from excessive and overwhelming tourism.
NICE,no linking again tho.This para is like 2-3 sentences,add a linking and it would be better
Social media certainly provides many social, environmental and political changes. Given this, it is more important than ever before for us to be aware of the benefits and negatives to social media.Maybe more detail.idk,I’m bad with conclusions
Thanks for reading, looking forward to writing more essays to post on this forum.

Also, I am happy to mark essays as I feel like its a great way for me to improve my own writing too.

Overall,it was great. Did not find much grammar errors(maybe cause I’m bad at grammar)
Intro conclusion need bit more detail
Should’ve put info for 2nd argument(if time ran out,it’s fine)
Sorry,I can’t provide much criticism since I’m like a really bad marker lol.
Definitely better than mine,great job 8)

EDIT:I JUST saw the topic,so If I said your argument is bad or something,my bad.It said socially n politically in the topic.My bad
« Last Edit: January 14, 2019, 03:24:41 pm by ProbotMelbourne »

The Progenitor

  • Trailblazer
  • *
  • Posts: 40
  • Respect: 0
Re: Essay Marking for the Selective School Exam
« Reply #113 on: January 14, 2019, 03:25:02 pm »
0
Thanks for the feedback probot. Keep in mind we still have 5 months so there is definitely tons of time to improve in every aspect. We are already quite far ahead of everyone if we are practicing this early. Feel free to send in essays, I have time to correct them.
« Last Edit: January 14, 2019, 03:28:14 pm by The Progenitor »

ProbotMelbourne

  • Forum Obsessive
  • ***
  • Posts: 210
  • Respect: 0
Re: Essay Marking for the Selective School Exam
« Reply #114 on: January 14, 2019, 03:58:29 pm »
0
Thanks for the feedback probot. Keep in mind we still have 5 months so there is definitely tons of time to improve in every aspect. We are already quite far ahead of everyone if we are practicing this early. Feel free to send in essays, I have time to correct them.

Thanks:)
U going for MHS?
I’ll probably upload an essay tonight,don’t have time rn since I’m at somebody’s house

The Progenitor

  • Trailblazer
  • *
  • Posts: 40
  • Respect: 0
Re: Essay Marking for the Selective School Exam
« Reply #115 on: January 14, 2019, 04:19:08 pm »
0
Yeah going for MHS, most likely won't get in, competition has been tough in the past few years apparently. However, 5 months is a long time to improve.

ProbotMelbourne

  • Forum Obsessive
  • ***
  • Posts: 210
  • Respect: 0
Re: Essay Marking for the Selective School Exam
« Reply #116 on: January 14, 2019, 04:23:36 pm »
0
Yeah going for MHS, most likely won't get in, competition has been tough in the past few years apparently. However, 5 months is a long time to improve.

Yeah,  :)Competition is tough.However,your maths is strong and so is ur English(ur essays) so you have a decent chance. I might go for SCHS since comp is a big easier.(^_-)Let’s keep practising and hopefully, we will get in

The Progenitor

  • Trailblazer
  • *
  • Posts: 40
  • Respect: 0
Re: Essay Marking for the Selective School Exam
« Reply #117 on: January 14, 2019, 04:38:13 pm »
0
To be blatantly honest, pretty much all the asians sitting the test would be pretty good at math. There could be a chance that my math may be good in my eyes, but be considered pretty average in front of 3000 others. I've started covering trigonometry and am pretty much done with quadratics, but there is probably more than 11% of the competition miles ahead of me.

ProbotMelbourne

  • Forum Obsessive
  • ***
  • Posts: 210
  • Respect: 0
Re: Essay Marking for the Selective School Exam
« Reply #118 on: January 14, 2019, 05:18:46 pm »
0
To be blatantly honest, pretty much all the asians sitting the test would be pretty good at math. There could be a chance that my math may be good in my eyes, but be considered pretty average in front of 3000 others. I've started covering trigonometry and am pretty much done with quadratics, but there is probably more than 11% of the competition miles ahead of me.

Trigonometry is like one of the last steps,so your miles ahead.I finished trig but I’m not that good at quadratics yet lol

ProbotMelbourne

  • Forum Obsessive
  • ***
  • Posts: 210
  • Respect: 0
Re: Essay Marking for the Selective School Exam
« Reply #119 on: January 14, 2019, 08:27:57 pm »
0
Hey guys!MY first creative essay which was untimed.Took around a hour tho lol,including everything.Your feedback helped me write this essay,so thanks.

Topic:A secret killed your father and you know what it was.

My grandchildren asked me a really personal question, ”what happened on the worst week of your life”?I did not want to reply, but the inner of me wanted to spit it all out.Thay say, ’a problem shared is a problem halved’. I began on my story of how my dad passed away, the worst week of my life.

It was an ordinary day, for everyone except my maid who was also my girlfriend and I. My father was on his chair reading his newspaper. My maid was cooking tea,while I was playing with checkers, alone. My mum was gone to the city to get some loaf. Us villagers had no shops or hospitals nearby. My mum also took her horse with her.

Our maid had served my dad some tea. “How bout add some sugar, will ya”?,my dad asked. My maid put some sugar then went away with a smile on her face. She gave me a wink then I did my role.
“Want some biscuits?”I asked.
“Sure,”he responded.
My dad munched on the biscuits and then immediately passed away. Our maid had mixed some chemicals which make my father unconscious for a week. I was drowning in happiness, my mum was coming next week and my father was unconscious, my maid and I chilled alone at home.

We watched black and white television together, she did not have to do work and we had no interruptions. Life was perfect, until we visited the haunted house nearby. She insisted to go, I did not mind either, so we went. Little had we known of your unexpected deadly journey ahead of us.

The haunted hosuss was spooky, especially at 3am, but we did not believe in ghosts. We moseyed up the stairs, spiderwebs tangled my hands and my girlfriend had to take it apart. When my girlfriend slammed the door open in front of us, a gust of wind chilled the warm air in the room. I took my hands out of my pocket and loosened my scarf, fresh and ready for my journey ahead

I was already mentally tired of today, so I took a break by sitting down on the chair. Unfortunately, the chair cracked open and I was covered with cotton.

The haunted house red rug was the only thing which actually creeped me out. The design and the fact it had hieroglyphics written on it blew my mind. The hieroglyphics formed a phrase, “maid and you killed father”. That sounded familiar of our journey today, except for the fact that we did not kill our father, or did we?

I cruised upstairs and saw several statues there. My girlfriend was checking out the statues as well. The black eyes and red teeth, with three toes and one nipple,were people really like that back then? We decided to head back since nothing fascinating or haunting(except for the rug) was in the house. As my maid and I were leaving,a statue raced to my maid and snatched her.The statue’s three eyes were beaming constantly. I stared in disbelief. The statue mumbled a language that I tried to decipher, but could not. The statue chucked my girlfriend near me and she finally spoke in English.
“Your maid killed your father, she mixed poison instead of chemicals which make you unconscious.
She has to die, for the sins she has done.”
“My father had died?Oh no,” I thought.
The statue zapped my maid, and my maid passed away in front of my eyes.

I dashed downstairs. I accidently slipped while the statue was after me. I rapidly got up and kept dashing down. I threw a vase, a sofa, a chess game at the statue but nothing harmed it. At last,I kicked the door and bolted back to my house. That is when I opened my door, and saw my father laying down on his chair,with poison on his mouth. I should not have done this. I wanted to be like others, not having my life controlled by my father, atleast for a week.

A week later, my mum also came back. She did not eat, walk, or even ask me what happened for a whole day. She just sat on my father,crying. I cried as well, of course.

A day later, my mum died from depression. Funerals did not exist back then so I left my mum and dad alone, in the house. I rode our horse to the city, to live a new life. I found a lovely girl, which is my wife. She also asked questions of what happened to my parents, but I did not say anything. It was a secret, that killed my father.

As I finished my story of how my father passed away, which was the worst week of my life, my grandchildren were fast asleep.

TWO THINGS
1.the maid n girlfriend are the same person
2.Would (“How about add some sugar,will you”?,my father asked.)make sense? Eg,the comma after the question mark.

Thanks for reading  8)