VCE Stuff > VCE Literature

How do I review a review? :O

(1/3) > >>

HungTran2009:
I need to review Ebert's review of Casablanca. I have no idea how to do this task. Any tips on how I should go about this???

You don't actually need to read the review to help me :)
But it's here if anyone is interested:
http://rogerebert.suntimes.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/19960915/REVIEWS08/401010308/1023

Thanks

EvangelionZeta:
You basically need to:

1. Establish Ebert's views on Casablanca and his interpretation.
2. Discuss HOW he shows these views in his review.
3. Evaluate how much his views make sense.
4. Offer your own views and back them up with conventional essay-style evidence.
5. Compare your view to his view (it CAN be the same).

iamdan08:

--- Quote from: EvangelionZeta on March 21, 2010, 11:43:03 am ---You basically need to:

1. Establish Ebert's views on Casablanca and his interpretation.
2. Discuss HOW he shows these views in his review.
3. Evaluate how much his views make sense.
4. Offer your own views and back them up with conventional essay-style evidence.
5. Compare your view to his view (it CAN be the same).

--- End quote ---

This.

If you like i can pm you a high scoring example. Have a read through the Lit board, as there is a bit of advice there a few threads down. :)

HungTran2009:
Thank you both!

Eriny:
Gotta love those meta-assignments :)
It's not as difficult as it seems. The advice above is really good. My advice would be to make your opinion somehow distinct from the review (even if only slightly).

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page