hey guys, i've read both of ur methods, and i saw the example odette's given on A+ bk, I've gone through a similar problem in TSFX further lectures, the way the guy did was to solve for P substituting the current value into A.
After some research, according to the inflation calculator on Forbes.com
http://www.forbes.com/cms/template/tools/calculator/investment_power.jhtml?_DARGS=%2Ffinance%2Fcalc%2Fgaininflation%2Fdroplet_form.jhtmlIf u sub Odette's example into it, Initial Investment = $1000000, Assumed average annual return:0% (since u still have the same amt after 20 years), Assumed Inflation Rate: 3%, Number of years: 20
U'll get the ans:
Nominal value of investment at end of period: $1,000,000.00
Inflation adjusted value of investment at end of period: $543,794.69
Which is the answer obtained by using Odette's way. I think that should be the right answer...
*Note the example specified in the A+ bk is another way of calculating depreciation using 0.97 as the depreciation factor... which means as money inflats, its purchasing or buying power effectively deflats/depreciates