General Footy Tipping and Discussion Thread

[brenden]

Today's the day we find out that Robbie Tarrant an AA backman

[Joseph41]

Higgins was a very good acquisition for North.

[brenden]

Higgins was a very good acquisition for North.

Yeah 100%. I think we've done very well. NDS, Higgins, Waite - even Hrovat. Soon to come - Kelly, Martin, and Fyfe

[Aaron]

Soon to come - Kelly, Martin, and Fyfe

Think only one with a real chance is Kelly. Fyfe won't leave freo.

P.S - First quarter.. wobbly. Not too bad, but not the best.

[Joseph41]

Yeah 100%. I think we've done very well. NDS, Higgins, Waite - even Hrovat. Soon to come - Kelly, Martin, and Fyfe

I admire your persistence.

[Aaron]

That. was. atrocious.

[vox nihili]

Does anybody on ATAR Notes support a good side? Hahaha.

yes 😏😏😏😏😏😏😏

[Joseph41]

yes 😏😏😏😏😏😏😏

Who might that be?

[howey]

Just did a ladder predictor. Finished with:

1. Greater Western Sydney
2. Adelaide
3. Western Bulldogs
4. Geelong
5. Port Adelaide
6. West Coast
7. Richmond
8. Fremantle

9. St. Kilda
10. Essendon
11. North Melbourne
12. Collingwood
13. Sydney
14. Melbourne
15. Gold Coast
16. Hawthorn
17. Carlton
18. Brisbane

Well I'd be estatic with that, as a Doggies fan.

[Joseph41]

Well I'd be estatic with that, as a Doggies fan.

I had you in mind, howey - didn't want to upset you.

[howey]

I had you in mind, howey - didn't want to upset you.

Good to hear. General question - who would you rather have at your side - Martin, Kelly or Fyfe?

[Joseph41]

Good to hear. General question - who would you rather have at your side - Martin, Kelly or Fyfe?

Clarification: do I only get them for this season, or for the remainder of their respective careers? And do I have to take into account what Melbourne would have to give up to get them?

[howey]

Clarification: do I only get them for this season, or for the remainder of their respective careers? And do I have to take into account what Melbourne would have to give up to get them?

Let's say for the rest of their careers. And no, don't worry about what you'd have to give up.

[Aaron]

I'll answer this anyway even though you directed it to Nick:

Kelly 100% if it's a long term deal. Young and already playing that good. Fyfe has flopped imo, not as good as he was a few years ago. Martin is good short term but getting old.

[howey]

I'll answer this anyway even though you directed it to Nick:

Kelly 100% if it's a long term deal. Young and already playing that good. Fyfe has flopped imo, not as good as he was a few years ago. Martin is good short term but getting old.

Yeah, I completely agree with you there - have to be Kelly given he's so young. What about if it was only for one year - would your answer change?