Login

Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.

September 27, 2025, 02:13:30 pm

Author Topic: Timed creative help!  (Read 1105 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

dcesaona

  • Forum Obsessive
  • ***
  • Posts: 202
  • Respect: +24
Timed creative help!
« on: October 11, 2018, 10:23:42 am »
0
Hi there! So I completed a timed creative practice and would greatly appreciate some feedback  ;D - particularly about whether or not I answered the question correctly (as this is always where I loose the most marks).

QUESTION:
Compose a piece of imaginative writing that focuses on the feeling of excitement or pleasure caused by a discovery. Use the image as a significant part of your response (I've attached the image for reference).

My earliest memory of my mother was watching her dance. She danced as though she were dancing on clouds, while I watched her in the sky, scared to step off the pathway up high and never being able to reach her. I watched as she whimsically whipped her tulle tutu around her slim body, never quite touching the clouds but always coming close. She danced with the melody, as the music swirled around her fluid movements. Up high in the sky, illuminated by the delicate golden tones of the sun, she was incandescent. The pathway to my mother would extend briefly when she took my hand and whisked me backstage. But afterwards my mother would float away from my grasp and become, once again, unreachable.

As a young girl, I attempted to build a pathway to my mother who danced in the sky. The baby pink ballet slippers comforted my small feet at the age of five. They were a beautiful beginning to what would be an inelegant end. Small ballerinas would line up on the barre and begin their routines. Our small legs would collapse under the strain of grande plies. We were unsteady but eager to explore this new world, like foals unsteady on their feet. Every now and then my mother would temporarily retreat down from her world up high in the clouds. She would run her kind hands gently across our bent arms and whisper, “lift up through your back”. Then she would ascend to her world of regality; a place I wished so desperately to be. I felt forever stuck on a pathway to nowhere in the clouds, so close to my mother, but so far away. My childhood was made up of these moments. The stale smell of the shoe shop, filled with the aroma of leather and lace, my mother trying on a shoe, bringing herself down towards the ground, where I waited eagerly in earnest. Looking up towards her, I never comprehended that she might begin to look down upon me.

The pointe shoe was cold and wooden, not as easily accepting as the slipper that had nurtured my feet in their tenderest years. I struggled to rekindle my dwindling interest, just as I fumbled miserably, trying to reach into the clouds and grasp hold of my mother. My muscles had become taut, entwined around my bones like the ribbons around my calves. I stood in the ballet studio, which was once full of life and warmth, but had now become cold and drab. My mother watched me from her position in the clouds with a long, hard stare. I mustered up the courage to ask, “have I let you down?” The silence that followed shattered into my skin like shards of glass. In a tone void of emotion, she replied, “no.” Her words pierced my pride, especially as I looked down at the beguiling pointe shoes in my hands, shimmering and strong. They masked my twisted and contorted feet, pushed to conform. I felt my mother drift endlessly away from me, hidden from me forever by the furling grey smoke of the clouds.
That night, after wallowing in my sadness, I made my way along that short path in the sky and found that it ended at my mother’s room. But when I pulled away the clouds, I found my mother, legs pulled tightly into her chest, with swollen, red eyes that matched my own. The image silenced and stunned me. My mother was always so regal and prim, but now she looked bent and twisted. With a voice full of sorrow and crackling with regret, she uttered, “I’m sorry”. I felt the path under my feet begin to extend towards my mother in the middle of the sky, and I slowly began to follow it. With each new step, excitement began bubbling up inside of me, as my vision of her began to appear glassy, as though I could finally see her without the white tufts of smoke swirling around her.

“For what?” I naively asked, stepping too far off the edge of my path in eagerness.

“Because I used you to keep myself interested in the one thing that holds something for me”, she added, and I saw her body deflate.

The path was now directly at my mother’s feet, for the first time ever. I felt a relief wash over me, as though I were finally able to untie the metal chains that twisted elegantly around my legs. My mother stepped from the weightless clouds, and joined me on my path. I realised that my mother was foolish for making me go through her pain, but I also felt free. I had built my footpath in the clouds since I was a child, always aiming for one destination. And I had finally reached it. My mother was no longer untouchable or far from my reach. I didn’t have to extend my despaired hands hopelessly into the clouds to find her, because she was standing right in front of me.
2018 HSC

LochNess Monster

  • Forum Regular
  • **
  • Posts: 70
  • I speak Chinglish!
  • Respect: +12
Re: Timed creative help!
« Reply #1 on: October 12, 2018, 06:28:28 pm »
+2
Can I be a critic?

Ok I'm going to sound a bit harsh but hopefully this helps both you and me to improve our writing together.  :)

So your beginning was great. I loved how she as a child looks up to her mum.

Problem was your middle was so rushed I felt a bit lost after a while. To slow it down (instead of writing more, because I know you are in exam conditions) add one or two long sentences to make the marker (and the reader) feel like lots of time has passed. Tim Winton does this very well, usually by showing the changing seasons and weather, as well as through sounds and character relationships. For example, in Neighbours he writes: "In the autumn..." "Not long after..." "As autumn merged into winter and the vermilion sunsets were followed by sudden, dark dusks touched with the smell of wood smoke and the sound of rooster's crowing the days end, the young couple found themselves..." Poems are also great for showing lapses in time.

Or my personal favourite, I love to always chuck in a clock to show passing of time. Just the tick tock in a lonely bedroom or simpler yet if I'm running out of time, the next couple of years/days/etc or an evening night sky turning to morning...

So maybe a line or two like that would help me as a reader regain my pace during the middle where you change too quickly from happy pleasurable feelings to sad, upset and confused. It was a super abrupt transition where I was left awkwardly trying to catch-up to her feelings...

Also, I would say don't make the end so obvious. Let it be a little bit subtler, roll on the tongue, savouring it kind-of-thing. Like instead of saying she knows her mother was wrong, make them share an action. Like let them hug each other or something. Sometimes actions speak louder than words. ;D Or let a tear roll down her cheek. She knows she doesn't have to be perfect anymore and that is such an exciting and relieving feeling.

All of your dialogue was really good. I enjoyed the silence and talking interactions between mother and daughter. Felt very real.
I  also loved the ideas of discovery and your writing, both of which were quite strong throughout, imao (I don't know, i'm no hsc marker. just another struggling year 12 student).  :'(

Your favourite line that tugged at me was your last sentence "she was standing right in front of me." That was a beautiful ending to a creative and discovery rolled into one.

This was an awesome first draft, especially under time limits and stress! I applaud you and hope I can get to read more of your stories.
I definitely enjoyed this one.  ;) Keep going.

Hope all my feedback will help you
ATAR: 89.55
⸜( ˙ ˘ ˙)/ ・゚☆✧ Sometimes wrong numbers are the right numbers ~ Cecelia Ahern

☽ “But I, being poor, have only my dreams;
I have spread my dreams under your feet;
Tread softly because you tread on my dreams.” - Yeats

dcesaona

  • Forum Obsessive
  • ***
  • Posts: 202
  • Respect: +24
Re: Timed creative help!
« Reply #2 on: October 13, 2018, 11:12:04 am »
0
Can I be a critic?

Ok I'm going to sound a bit harsh but hopefully this helps both you and me to improve our writing together.  :)

So your beginning was great. I loved how she as a child looks up to her mum.

Problem was your middle was so rushed I felt a bit lost after a while. To slow it down (instead of writing more, because I know you are in exam conditions) add one or two long sentences to make the marker (and the reader) feel like lots of time has passed. Tim Winton does this very well, usually by showing the changing seasons and weather, as well as through sounds and character relationships. For example, in Neighbours he writes: "In the autumn..." "Not long after..." "As autumn merged into winter and the vermilion sunsets were followed by sudden, dark dusks touched with the smell of wood smoke and the sound of rooster's crowing the days end, the young couple found themselves..." Poems are also great for showing lapses in time.

Or my personal favourite, I love to always chuck in a clock to show passing of time. Just the tick tock in a lonely bedroom or simpler yet if I'm running out of time, the next couple of years/days/etc or an evening night sky turning to morning...

So maybe a line or two like that would help me as a reader regain my pace during the middle where you change too quickly from happy pleasurable feelings to sad, upset and confused. It was a super abrupt transition where I was left awkwardly trying to catch-up to her feelings...

Also, I would say don't make the end so obvious. Let it be a little bit subtler, roll on the tongue, savouring it kind-of-thing. Like instead of saying she knows her mother was wrong, make them share an action. Like let them hug each other or something. Sometimes actions speak louder than words. ;D Or let a tear roll down her cheek. She knows she doesn't have to be perfect anymore and that is such an exciting and relieving feeling.

All of your dialogue was really good. I enjoyed the silence and talking interactions between mother and daughter. Felt very real.
I  also loved the ideas of discovery and your writing, both of which were quite strong throughout, imao (I don't know, i'm no hsc marker. just another struggling year 12 student).  :'(

Your favourite line that tugged at me was your last sentence "she was standing right in front of me." That was a beautiful ending to a creative and discovery rolled into one.

This was an awesome first draft, especially under time limits and stress! I applaud you and hope I can get to read more of your stories.
I definitely enjoyed this one.  ;) Keep going.

Hope all my feedback will help you

Thank you sooo much for your feedback!! I definitely get what you mean with the passing time thing, it is a very abrupt jump from emotions, but I love your suggestions on how to ease the reader more comfortably into that transition. I never thought of that! I also understand the discovery thing and making it no so obvious. It's hard that the markers expect a subtle discovery but also a discovery that is obviously answering the question, you have to find this really tricky balance which is easy to get off. They expect so much agghhh. But again, thanks for your feedback! I'd be happy to read and provide feedback on your writing if you'd like too!




2018 HSC