Spoiler
Discuss the powerful ways that significant ideas are explored in your prescribed text.
The unique imagery within creative mediums such as poetry to represent meaning and encourage powerful responses from their audiences. A little issue with expression here, doesn't quite flow properly - But I like the idea being presented! In T.S Eliot's poems, “The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock” and “The Hollow Men”, the imagery is quite effective in challenging and criticising the nature of the modern world, which is a common theme being conveyed throughout using powerful devices. Watch the use of 'quite,' it makes you seem a little unsure of your argument, try and avoid low modality language like this! Eliot criticises the modern world as fragmented and dreary towards the start of the 20th century. The dull urban environments that are explored in his poems represents a society of metaphorical deterioration and decay, which demonstrates his overall perspective of the modernity and isolation in the everyday lives of modern man. Good! I'd like a little more detail as to the sorts of critiques Elliot is presenting though, just a little vague right now. Ultimately, Eliot’s ideas effectively highlight the concern of modern man as a whole whilst emphasising the meaningless and monotony of the life of the modern man. Solid introduction - A few little expression issues, and I'd also want a little more detail about exactly the sort of things Elliot wants to communicate to the audience. However, very good start!
Creative forms such as poetry utilise distinct imagery to evoke meaning and purpose to motivate dynamic responses from their audiences. This is very much the same statement as your Thesis - I'd expect you to hone in on something more specific in a paragraph, some specific concept. In his poem “The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock”, Eliot portrays the landscape through dark imagery of “half-deserted streets...that follow like a tedious argument of insidious intent”, highlighting Eliot’s criticism that the everyday modern life is a monotony and menacing like the navigation of dark, “half-deserted streets”. Fantastic. Ultimately, this deserting imagery gives no meaning to the lives of the modern individual. Eliot adopts a different form of poem structure and punctuation than regular poetic forms because, in Love Song, he has created the first stanza as one sentence over multiple lines; expressing Eliot’s own beliefs that the everyday modern life is non-linear. Nice reference to structure, lots of people ignore it. Great analysis. The powerful urban decay imagery is employed to explore society's disease that has resulted from the rise of modernity. Example? Eliot shows the urban squalor in the form of “restless nights in one-night cheap hotels” as he examines the decay in morals and human life that has infected us in the deterioration of the past regimes. A little unsure what you mean by this point, also missing a technique (or was this linked to the previous sentence?) Further imagery depicted in the personification of the “yellow smoke that rubbed its muzzle on the window panes” highlights Eliot's allusion to the industrialisation of modern society as a new century begins with the yellow smoke drawing relation between Eliot's view of the city squalor as a result of the rapid industrialisation of the modern world; highlighting his negative perception of the sickness of modernity. Fantastic analysis, but I think the expression here could be a little more direct and to the point, to avoid using the words 'yellow smoke' twice. Eliot's use of feline imagery compares Prufrock's evasion of human connection yet wanting to be connected, which highlight Eliot's dissatisfaction with modern society's lack of courage. The cockroach imagery, "pinned and wriggling on the wall" uses urban imagery, in such a way, to convey Eliot's criticism of modern man's oblivious and cowardly nature. Be sure your paragraph has a proper conclusion - But this is a fantastic paragraph, excellent analysis. I'd like your expression to be a little more direct to make it a little easier for the reader to interpret your ideas.
Moreover, in “The Hollow Men”, Eliot further explores the empty, pointless, and meaningless nature of modern life. Good. Eliot emphasises the deteriorating morality of society throughout his poem, which reflects his disappointment with traditional values in post-war modernity. Eliot draws comparison between modern man and “men made of straw” highlighting their existence and lack of moral standards, thus emphasising the hopelessness of Eliot’s perception of the modern world. Technique for that quote? Also, in The Hollow Men, the persona says “this is the way the world ends, this is the way the world ends, this is the way the world ends, not with a bang but a whimper”, which challenges the belief of man’s constant advancement in society and the world; further reinforcing the meaningless, futile nature of modern life that will only cause our own destruction because of our inability to construct a functional, meaningful society. Again, technique? Be careful you aren't just using things said in the poem to push arguments, the focus needs to be on techniques, how the composer uses them to present ideas to the audience. Furthermore, the poem begins with “we are the hollow men, we are the stuffed men” as Eliot juxtaposes the ideas of people being “hollow” and “stuffed” at the same time to show the idea that modern life cannot be understood. The audience is also included in Eliot’s idea with the repetition of “we are” to reinforce the overarching “hollow” nature of the modern world and the current generation. Not as analytically strong as your first paragraph, I'm missing the techniques in this one!
Ultimately, the ideas in both ‘The Love Song of J Alfred Prufrock’ and ‘The Hollow Men’ have emphasised Eliot’s perception of the futile theme of modern man and the sickness of modernity at the beginning of the 20th century. Eliot has explored ideas overarching the incompetence of the society and relationships between the individual and the modern world.
I think this is a very strong essay in terms of its analysis - Especially that first paragraph. Focus on techniques, no retell, did an excellent job there!! Not quite as strong in the 2nd paragraph though - You need more techniques to sustain the argument.
Probably my biggest overall comment would be conceptual clarity. Often it feels like the argument is a little vague, just "modern world is bad." I think it's mostly a structural thing, making sure it is really clear what you'll be arguing from the start and honing in on specific concepts in your paragraph. Don't get me wrong, what you've got works well, but it could be better
you might also want to consider adding a third paragraph for a little more depth?
A few little expression issues too, but overall, nice work!! I think the ideas are great and the analysis is, on the whole, very effective