So I was looking through my trial paper:
"A solution was made by mixing sodium acetate solid and a solution of acetic acid. Use an equation to predict and explain the impact on the pH of the solution of adding a very small volume of hydrochloric acid to this mixture".
I said: The impact of the mixture is negligible due to the buffer solution of CH3COOH and CH3COONa, as the CH3COO- ion is a weak conjugate base of the weak acid CH3COONa (as per required for a buffer solution). When HCl is added: HCl(aq) + CH3COONa(aq) --> NaCl (aq) + CH3COOH(aq), it is neutralised. pH change will thus be resisted, creating a weaker acid and neutral salt.
I got 1/2...is this wrong/how could I have gotten full marks? There was a cross on top of my equation - was this where I went wrong?
Thanks! 😊
1. It is not negligible, because something small happens and it gets recovered but something still happens that's not minuscule.
2. You did not properly relate to Le Chatelier's principle
3. You did not write the equation of the buffer system (identification that there was a buffer was probably the mark)
When the buffer system was formed, the following equilibrium was established (noting that the Na
+ is a neutral, spectator cation.
CH
3COO
- + H
3O
+ <-> CH
3COOH
(aq) + H
2O
(l)Because the solution was made by combining the substances, both of which are a weak base/acid respectively, the above buffer system is formed. The buffer will resist small changes in pH, which you mentioned but not explained in the correct way.
When a small quantity of HCl is added, we introduce some H
3O
+ into the system. So by LCP, the equilibrium will shift to the right, producing more acetic acid and water.
Now the purpose of a buffer to resist pH changes is like so. There are two things to keep in mind.
1. By shifting the equilibrium to the right, we have eliminated some of the strong HCl and introduced more weak CH
3COOH.
2. The fact that there is both CH
3COO
- AND CH
3COOH imply that the pH of the mixture is quite stable. There's both acidic and basic substances in there, and hence the concentrations of acidic and basic substances are pretty stable, implying the pH doesn't change so easily.
In adding the strong acid, note that by LCP it just gets converted to a weak acid, which is a part of the buffer. Hence the pH will increase, however by a smaller amount than if the buffer was not there.
You can determine where you lost the marks and what you would've needed to get them. Obviously since it was 2 marks not AS much depth is required here, but you can determine where the mark lost was.