Hey! Would appreciate if someone could give me a rough mark indication for my response to the last question of 2015 Paper 1.
Compare how TWO of the texts represent the significance of curiosity in the process of discovering.
Discoveries, particularly the physical, can be significantly influenced by one’s curiosity, however the factor of necessity in certain discoveries cannot be disregarded. This is true of a comparison of text 1, which highlights the necessity of physical discovery that poverty invokes, and text 3, which epitomises the utmost lengths that the call go to in order to discover and satisfy their curiosity. Text 1 incorporates a jarring juxtaposition of the complexity of the language used for the characters dialogue, for example ‘Oh man, look at this!’ to the ‘voluminous pair of white rayan bleachers’. This exemplifies the situation of poverty the couple are in, prompting them to undergo a physical discovery for everyday items cut of sheer necessity. The couple portrayed in the extract are often in awe of what they find, the short, sudden exclamation such as ‘This!’ convey the dire situation they are in, that they have an appreciation towards the smallest of physical discoveries evoked entirely by necessity. This diminishes the importance of curiosity in the search for everyday items. The reaction of the responder is minimised by the wealthier British tourist, who are ‘disgusted’ by this utmost necessity. However, a different portrayal of the significance of curiosity in initiating physical discovery is evident in Text 3, Atwood’s Butterfly. The father’s appreciation for nature in his ‘three move walk through the forest to school’ is accomplished through the use of lyricism and cumulative listing as ‘he noticed everything; mushroom and scat, wild bloom, snail and , clunkmoss, fern and career’. This epitomises the father’s attunement towards nature, accounting for the great extent of curiosity the father has garnered in search of the ‘butterfly, as blue as eyes’. This curiosity is represented as the father had ‘the wish to know and the need to pracse’, prompting ‘that set him off his tangent’, and epitomising the importance of curiosity towards the father’s discovery. The description of the mapping ‘microscopes and numbers, candle pins, cars, undurings’ demonstrates the extent that the father is willing to go to satisfy his curiosity, evoked by the physical discovery of the butterfly. As such, a contrast of Text 1 and 3 epitomises that both necessity and curiosity are factors that drive individuals to physical discovery, depending in the situation.
Sorry if there are errors, got someone to type it up for me.
TIA!