Login

Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.

July 24, 2025, 07:02:55 am

Author Topic: Free AOS Creative Writing Marking!  (Read 352969 times)

0 Members and 5 Guests are viewing this topic.

jamonwindeyer

  • Honorary Moderator
  • Great Wonder of ATAR Notes
  • *******
  • Posts: 10149
  • The lurker from the north.
Re: Free AOS Creative Writing Marking!
« Reply #390 on: October 12, 2016, 07:05:32 pm »
thanks jamon! i'll go over and edit the parts you've mentioned. I really appreciate that you've marked this at this point in time.
thankyou so much :)

Not a problem at all; best of luck! ;D

anotherworld2b

  • Forum Leader
  • ****
  • Posts: 747
  • School Grad Year: 2017
Re: Free AOS Creative Writing Marking!
« Reply #391 on: October 12, 2016, 07:19:56 pm »
Hi I was wondering if I could get my story marked please  ;D
Spoiler
1. Construct an opinion piece, speech or  narrative to position an audience to respond in a particular way to the image provided.
Statement of intent: It focuses on the male character response to finalising his divorce with his wife
The image: pictured two monochromatic people, one male and one female back to back

The office was cold, and outside ethereal rays of light from the sun shone gently on the  grass and flowers covered with glistening morning dew. His fingertips gently glided over the smooth paper as he looked at the numerous scribbles and daunting numbers on the last page of the document. The movement of his calloused fingers halted, hovering over the straight line next to the daunting and bold word ‘Signature’ once again. A familiar blur and sting fill his eyes as he closed his eyes engraving waves of lines into his forehead.

Now out beyond him were the vibrant red roses, tulips and peonies he loved arranged neatly in the flower beds. The nostalgic gentle breeze of spring blew her golden hair astray as she tended to her precious flowers with great care. A familiar gentle arch appeared on his face as he slowly approached her from behind. She let out a gasp of surprise and a melodious laugh as he enveloped her tightly in his grasp with loud laughter of his own. At night the familiar feeling of cotton would brush against his feet as he intertwined his fingers with hers gazing up vast and open night sky. He would teach her the names of constellations with passion as she looked at him with a wide eyed smile on her face. The chirping of crickets and stillness of the night would bask them in comfortable silence despite no words being spoken.

He could feel more tears trailing down his face dripping onto the white paper and the cold surface of his mahogany desk seeped through his silk shirt. The sound of laughter and noise was replaced by silence and the ticking of a clock. He took a deep breath and held a pen tight in his grip so tight his knuckles turned white. Signing the document with his signature finalising their separation.

jamonwindeyer

  • Honorary Moderator
  • Great Wonder of ATAR Notes
  • *******
  • Posts: 10149
  • The lurker from the north.
Re: Free AOS Creative Writing Marking!
« Reply #392 on: October 12, 2016, 07:26:49 pm »
Hi I was wondering if I could get my story marked please  ;D
Spoiler
1. Construct an opinion piece, speech or  narrative to position an audience to respond in a particular way to the image provided.
Statement of intent: It focuses on the male character response to finalising his divorce with his wife
The image: pictured two monochromatic people, one male and one female back to back

The office was cold, and outside ethereal rays of light from the sun shone gently on the  grass and flowers covered with glistening morning dew. His fingertips gently glided over the smooth paper as he looked at the numerous scribbles and daunting numbers on the last page of the document. The movement of his calloused fingers halted, hovering over the straight line next to the daunting and bold word ‘Signature’ once again. A familiar blur and sting fill his eyes as he closed his eyes engraving waves of lines into his forehead.

Now out beyond him were the vibrant red roses, tulips and peonies he loved arranged neatly in the flower beds. The nostalgic gentle breeze of spring blew her golden hair astray as she tended to her precious flowers with great care. A familiar gentle arch appeared on his face as he slowly approached her from behind. She let out a gasp of surprise and a melodious laugh as he enveloped her tightly in his grasp with loud laughter of his own. At night the familiar feeling of cotton would brush against his feet as he intertwined his fingers with hers gazing up vast and open night sky. He would teach her the names of constellations with passion as she looked at him with a wide eyed smile on her face. The chirping of crickets and stillness of the night would bask them in comfortable silence despite no words being spoken.

He could feel more tears trailing down his face dripping onto the white paper and the cold surface of his mahogany desk seeped through his silk shirt. The sound of laughter and noise was replaced by silence and the ticking of a clock. He took a deep breath and held a pen tight in his grip so tight his knuckles turned white. Signing the document with his signature finalising their separation.

Hey hey! Since you are a Prelim student, we'll get this marked for you after the current Year 12 HSC English Exams are done, just to make sure we're giving the help where its needed most over the next few days! ;D

katherine123

  • Trendsetter
  • **
  • Posts: 120
  • School Grad Year: 2016
Re: Free AOS Creative Writing Marking!
« Reply #393 on: October 12, 2016, 07:45:07 pm »
- If i am asked to include a vague quote "suddenly, everything slips aside..." in the first sentence of creative, how am i or am i suppose to repeat the idea from the quote throughout my creative?

-If the given quote is in 1st person, will it be okay if i integrate it as an internal dialogue so i can avoid changing my creative into 1st person?

-If the ques asks me to use a quote as central element not as part of creative (eg. attached below) , is it okay if i include the exact quote in my creative and then repeat the central idea throughout?


do you provide  same number of techniques as the marks given for unseen texts?

« Last Edit: October 12, 2016, 08:04:12 pm by katherine123 »

anotherworld2b

  • Forum Leader
  • ****
  • Posts: 747
  • School Grad Year: 2017
Re: Free AOS Creative Writing Marking!
« Reply #394 on: October 12, 2016, 07:49:35 pm »
when will the exams over? Will it be the same for other threads as well?
Hey hey! Since you are a Prelim student, we'll get this marked for you after the current Year 12 HSC English Exams are done, just to make sure we're giving the help where its needed most over the next few days! ;D

ladyofathena

  • Adventurer
  • *
  • Posts: 15
Re: Free AOS Creative Writing Marking!
« Reply #395 on: October 12, 2016, 08:05:24 pm »
when will the exams over? Will it be the same for other threads as well?

For English, the exams are on tomorrow and Friday
All the HSC exams finish on the 4th of November :)
2016 ATAR - 99.15
Adv English - 93
Mathematics Ext 1 - 95
Mathematics Ext 2 - 89
Chemistry - 91
Physics - 91

anotherworld2b

  • Forum Leader
  • ****
  • Posts: 747
  • School Grad Year: 2017
Re: Free AOS Creative Writing Marking!
« Reply #396 on: October 12, 2016, 08:12:04 pm »
I wish everyone with exams with the best of luck  :)
For English, the exams are on tomorrow and Friday
All the HSC exams finish on the 4th of November :)

jamonwindeyer

  • Honorary Moderator
  • Great Wonder of ATAR Notes
  • *******
  • Posts: 10149
  • The lurker from the north.
Re: Free AOS Creative Writing Marking!
« Reply #397 on: October 12, 2016, 10:16:05 pm »
- If i am asked to include a vague quote "suddenly, everything slips aside..." in the first sentence of creative, how am i or am i suppose to repeat the idea from the quote throughout my creative?

-If the given quote is in 1st person, will it be okay if i integrate it as an internal dialogue so i can avoid changing my creative into 1st person?

-If the ques asks me to use a quote as central element not as part of creative (eg. attached below) , is it okay if i include the exact quote in my creative and then repeat the central idea throughout?


do you provide  same number of techniques as the marks given for unseen texts?

Hey Katherine! So if the question just says to start the creative with that quote, then that is all you need to do. The idea doesn't need to be permeated through (though the story needs to make sense, you can't just have them on a cliff and then randomly in a church for no reason ;))

Your ideas for the inclusion of the quote are both spot on! :)

As for marks vs techniques:

1 Mark: 1 Technique
2 Marks: 2 Techniques
3 Marks: 3-4 Techniques
4 Marks: 4-5 Techniques
5+ Marks: 7+ Techniques

There is a big jump for the 5 marker; you need quit a bit of depth to really make sure you get the marks!! :)


elysepopplewell

  • HSC Lecturer
  • Honorary Moderator
  • ATAR Notes Legend
  • *******
  • Posts: 3236
  • "Hey little fighter, soon it will be brighter."
Re: Free AOS Creative Writing Marking!
« Reply #398 on: October 12, 2016, 10:20:47 pm »
- If i am asked to include a vague quote "suddenly, everything slips aside..." in the first sentence of creative, how am i or am i suppose to repeat the idea from the quote throughout my creative?

-If the given quote is in 1st person, will it be okay if i integrate it as an internal dialogue so i can avoid changing my creative into 1st person?

-If the ques asks me to use a quote as central element not as part of creative (eg. attached below) , is it okay if i include the exact quote in my creative and then repeat the central idea throughout?


do you provide  same number of techniques as the marks given for unseen texts?

About the initial quote: If they specify that it needs to be the first sentence of your creative, you're unlikely to need to keep referring to it. If they specify it as the "central element" - that's where you need to refer consistently. But if it is the first sentence and that's all they specify, you have freedom.

Definitely okay to work with the narration like that :)

Third question: Yep! That sounds perfect!!

4th question: Not necessarily. If you want to go by that guide it won't be to your detriment, but it won't guarantee marks. For a two marker that says, "Describe the use of metaphor in relation to discovery" it might give you a mark for identifying the idea and location of the metaphor, and a second mark for explaining it's implications in the text, for example. So not necessarily two techniques there. :)
Not sure how to navigate around ATAR Notes? Check out this video!

Sanaz

  • Trailblazer
  • *
  • Posts: 45
Re: Free AOS Creative Writing Marking!
« Reply #399 on: October 12, 2016, 10:32:49 pm »
Hey can I get my creative looked at? I am really nervous about tomorrow...

jamonwindeyer

  • Honorary Moderator
  • Great Wonder of ATAR Notes
  • *******
  • Posts: 10149
  • The lurker from the north.
Re: Free AOS Creative Writing Marking!
« Reply #400 on: October 12, 2016, 10:35:18 pm »
Hey can I get my creative looked at? I am really nervous about tomorrow...

Upload it here Sanaz! We'll give it a really quick read for you :)

(you can add an attachment with the button below where you type your posts)

Sanaz

  • Trailblazer
  • *
  • Posts: 45
Re: Free AOS Creative Writing Marking!
« Reply #401 on: October 12, 2016, 10:38:52 pm »
Hey can I get my creative looked at? I am really nervous about tomorrow...
Green with Envy

Winston Eastwood observed the tantalising golden medal resting in front of him. It lured him like a desperate siren.  

“George Forest,” called the announcer snapping Winston out of his reverie realising that only the best and brightest could receive the prize.

“Loner!” shouted Winston as the boy walked down the stage. “Wimp, stupid, loser,” Winston propelled insults directed at the lanky boy, whilst he felt a reassuring nudge on his back.

Everyone laughed.

Winston smirked at the prize.

That night, he stamped on the tallest poppy resting on his windowsill and with that let the cluster of memories sieve out of his porous mind, which allowed him to forget that he had chosen the crowd. Forget that the boy was not indeed a loser.

***
Cold wind pierced his leathery skin as he unzipped his adidas bag and tied a black rope across his checkered apron.

Monstrous buildings towered above him and the green poster with the once frazzled boy neatly arranged in a suit. The end of his golden chain was like a phantom limb weighing down his chest with guilt. He caressed the simmering medallion It was heavy, consumed of success, overwhelming Winston with the guilty burden. He brushed a hand through his sweaty curls, plastered onto his forehead, wrinkled with years of stress.

“You’re late again Winston, make me a chai latte, skim milk and two sugars and deliver It to block 37! Pronto!” Reynolds glared at him with slate grey beady eyes.

Car horns honked furiously, pushing and heaving the heavy traffic like viscous honey. Passers by chugged coffee, gulping like savage animals. Women in tight dresses clicked their heels onto the asphalt. Their hair was tucked perfectly in symmetrical buns and the men had theirs gelled in sharp jarring angles.

A cacophony of posters polluted the streets in herds and the banners decorated the streets, dripping with green.

“Vote green. Save our world. Vote for a brighter future and vote Forest!” The jungle of clones protested in front of the voting centre in a rhythmic march.

A pamphlet slid into Winston’s hands and once a whimper, the grin stretched across the page preserving the insults he had once tortured the boy with. Buildings towered menacingly above him, puncturing the happiness from the clouds and absorbing the sun’s silver rays. They leered like spectators with ravenous hunger as early morning commuters trudged behind robotically. Their faces were encrusted with decade-old grime and suffocated between a thick blanketing haze. Winston threw the pamphlet in the recycling bin. His stocky frame blended with the harsh lines of the angry city.

Winston watched him enter the centre. Bitter bile clogged his throat.

Everything was muted, the auditorium silencing in his presence. He approached a microphone and a confident voice escaped his thin lips, crushing Winston’s dreams with every heavy step he took.

And in an instant as if seeing it all again, Winston’s mind raced back to a time in where he was nineteen. The same brown hair in a modern comb over stared back at him. A line was shaved in his part. His suit was handsomely pressed. The boy next to him also had his shirt ironed, and the same line was shaved in his part. And despite the artificial smile attached to his face, a quiver escaped his small lips. And Winston drowned. He drowned in the sea of clones surrounding him.

But a lanky boy stood out amidst the sea of sheep.

Winston looked at him, his chest constricted, his forehead damp.

The tattered jeans and outdated shag reflected in the shiny metal made it ridiculous for anyone to believe he was even associated with his man in a different time.

Clutching his sides Winston gulped for breath after sprinting out of the centre.

He tried to piece together how this could be, how such a…a loser could become something better than him. Now he didn’t have anything but the plain shards of its memory stabbing at him like a dull knife. He couldn’t recall why he had become the loser he had been trying to avoid his entire life.

The crowd of green drones followed George like unfed pets begging for attention. George’s voice droned on in the background, a slight whisper caressing him.

“Good morning my loyal supporters,

I am George Forest and, electing me will lead to drastic change in your city. I’d like to build a green wall along Sydney tower and let us Sydney-siders salvage our dying nation. I will make your health a priority, and monitor air quality readings daily.”

“We want green!” Cheered the supporters.

George rushed out of the centre heedless of the clutching hands and questioning voices, parting the sea of heads with his outstretched arms.

Hot brown liquid splashed onto Winston’s arm leaving a scalding reminder of George’s burning eyes as he was pushed over by the buzzing crowd.

“Get off me,” George sneered and the once perfect smile scowled into a bitter grimace. “And by the way don’t forget to vote for me of course,” he chuckled sardonically.

The giant billboard mocked him, and like a vicious cancer burgeoning through the city its gaze burnt Winston’s pride. But what was the use of this pride if it was going to isolate him?

Winston refused to keep such a demeaning object. He snapped the medal in his fingers and shards of yellow plastic scattered surrounding him.

Outside the voting centre red poppies emerged through the soil and their deep, rich-red petals coloured the grass.

George left as Winston observed a single green note escape his briefcase, gently landing on the tallest poppy.


Sanaz

  • Trailblazer
  • *
  • Posts: 45
Re: Free AOS Creative Writing Marking!
« Reply #402 on: October 12, 2016, 10:46:12 pm »
Upload it here Sanaz! We'll give it a really quick read for you :)

(you can add an attachment with the button below where you type your posts)

sorry for not sending it earlier... I was too nervous lol

jamonwindeyer

  • Honorary Moderator
  • Great Wonder of ATAR Notes
  • *******
  • Posts: 10149
  • The lurker from the north.
Re: Free AOS Creative Writing Marking!
« Reply #403 on: October 12, 2016, 11:06:01 pm »
Green with Envy

Cool! Your creative is in the spoiler and my comments are below it:

Spoiler
Winston Eastwood observed the tantalising golden medal resting in front of him. It lured him like a desperate siren. 

“George Forest,” called the announcer snapping Winston out of his reverie realising that only the best and brightest could receive the prize.

“Loner!” shouted Winston as the boy walked down the stage. “Wimp, stupid, loser,” Winston propelled insults directed at the lanky boy, whilst he felt a reassuring nudge on his back.

Everyone laughed.

Winston smirked at the prize.

That night, he stamped on the tallest poppy resting on his windowsill and with that let the cluster of memories sieve out of his porous mind, which allowed him to forget that he had chosen the crowd. Forget that the boy was not indeed a loser.

***
Cold wind pierced his leathery skin as he unzipped his adidas bag and tied a black rope across his checkered apron.

Monstrous buildings towered above him and the green poster with the once frazzled boy neatly arranged in a suit. The end of his golden chain was like a phantom limb weighing down his chest with guilt. He caressed the simmering medallion It was heavy, consumed of success, overwhelming Winston with the guilty burden. He brushed a hand through his sweaty curls, plastered onto his forehead, wrinkled with years of stress.

“You’re late again Winston, make me a chai latte, skim milk and two sugars and deliver It to block 37! Pronto!” Reynolds glared at him with slate grey beady eyes.

Car horns honked furiously, pushing and heaving the heavy traffic like viscous honey. Passers by chugged coffee, gulping like savage animals. Women in tight dresses clicked their heels onto the asphalt. Their hair was tucked perfectly in symmetrical buns and the men had theirs gelled in sharp jarring angles.

A cacophony of posters polluted the streets in herds and the banners decorated the streets, dripping with green.

“Vote green. Save our world. Vote for a brighter future and vote Forest!” The jungle of clones protested in front of the voting centre in a rhythmic march.

A pamphlet slid into Winston’s hands and once a whimper, the grin stretched across the page preserving the insults he had once tortured the boy with. Buildings towered menacingly above him, puncturing the happiness from the clouds and absorbing the sun’s silver rays. They leered like spectators with ravenous hunger as early morning commuters trudged behind robotically. Their faces were encrusted with decade-old grime and suffocated between a thick blanketing haze. Winston threw the pamphlet in the recycling bin. His stocky frame blended with the harsh lines of the angry city.

Winston watched him enter the centre. Bitter bile clogged his throat.

Everything was muted, the auditorium silencing in his presence. He approached a microphone and a confident voice escaped his thin lips, crushing Winston’s dreams with every heavy step he took.

And in an instant as if seeing it all again, Winston’s mind raced back to a time in where he was nineteen. The same brown hair in a modern comb over stared back at him. A line was shaved in his part. His suit was handsomely pressed. The boy next to him also had his shirt ironed, and the same line was shaved in his part. And despite the artificial smile attached to his face, a quiver escaped his small lips. And Winston drowned. He drowned in the sea of clones surrounding him.

But a lanky boy stood out amidst the sea of sheep.

Winston looked at him, his chest constricted, his forehead damp.

The tattered jeans and outdated shag reflected in the shiny metal made it ridiculous for anyone to believe he was even associated with his man in a different time.

Clutching his sides Winston gulped for breath after sprinting out of the centre.

He tried to piece together how this could be, how such a…a loser could become something better than him. Now he didn’t have anything but the plain shards of its memory stabbing at him like a dull knife. He couldn’t recall why he had become the loser he had been trying to avoid his entire life.

The crowd of green drones followed George like unfed pets begging for attention. George’s voice droned on in the background, a slight whisper caressing him.

“Good morning my loyal supporters,

I am George Forest and, electing me will lead to drastic change in your city. I’d like to build a green wall along Sydney tower and let us Sydney-siders salvage our dying nation. I will make your health a priority, and monitor air quality readings daily.”

“We want green!” Cheered the supporters.

George rushed out of the centre heedless of the clutching hands and questioning voices, parting the sea of heads with his outstretched arms.

Hot brown liquid splashed onto Winston’s arm leaving a scalding reminder of George’s burning eyes as he was pushed over by the buzzing crowd.

“Get off me,” George sneered and the once perfect smile scowled into a bitter grimace. “And by the way don’t forget to vote for me of course,” he chuckled sardonically.

The giant billboard mocked him, and like a vicious cancer burgeoning through the city its gaze burnt Winston’s pride. But what was the use of this pride if it was going to isolate him?

Winston refused to keep such a demeaning object. He snapped the medal in his fingers and shards of yellow plastic scattered surrounding him.

Outside the voting centre red poppies emerged through the soil and their deep, rich-red petals coloured the grass.

George left as Winston observed a single green note escape his briefcase, gently landing on the tallest poppy.

Comments
- The first section, it is a little unclear what is happening. I think that's the intention, but even then, it's a bit too disorienting for my taste. Perhaps some description of the setting could help there?
- Some really cool imagery and word choice as the creative progresses, setting a really nice tone to the story. You have a cool writing style!
- Further, you do a really good job of portraying the emotional state of your protagonist. I'm inside their head, which is awesome! However, I'm still a TAD confused as to the exact specifics of what is happening by the middle. I get it, but I feel like I'm working a tad too hard to get it if you catch me. Be sure your plot is clear!
- The speech given by George is a little forced. It's not how a political speech would read, not a huge deal
- Not 100% sure of the significance of the Poppy motif

I think you are a really fantastic writer; I'll start with that. You've got some cool use of language here and you create a fantastic tone really quickly. You've got your style and it works really well for you! Really my biggest comment is that I'm not really getting a Discovery concept out of this. Be sure that when you head in tomorrow, you are actively thinking, "What do I want to say about Discovery?" That will inevitably get you thinking about it throughout, and that will translate into the concept being more obvious in your story! I know it is there now, but I'm looking for it to shine through a bit more :)

sorry for not sending it earlier... I was too nervous lol

Don't be!! I think this is really great, if you just really keep Discovery in your head when you write it tomorrow, then the concept will naturally be stronger, which is the only really big suggestion I'd make. You will smash it! Good luck :)

Sanaz

  • Trailblazer
  • *
  • Posts: 45
Re: Free AOS Creative Writing Marking!
« Reply #404 on: October 12, 2016, 11:15:40 pm »
Cool! Your creative is in the spoiler and my comments are below it:

Spoiler
Winston Eastwood observed the tantalising golden medal resting in front of him. It lured him like a desperate siren. 

“George Forest,” called the announcer snapping Winston out of his reverie realising that only the best and brightest could receive the prize.

“Loner!” shouted Winston as the boy walked down the stage. “Wimp, stupid, loser,” Winston propelled insults directed at the lanky boy, whilst he felt a reassuring nudge on his back.

Everyone laughed.

Winston smirked at the prize.

That night, he stamped on the tallest poppy resting on his windowsill and with that let the cluster of memories sieve out of his porous mind, which allowed him to forget that he had chosen the crowd. Forget that the boy was not indeed a loser.

***
Cold wind pierced his leathery skin as he unzipped his adidas bag and tied a black rope across his checkered apron.

Monstrous buildings towered above him and the green poster with the once frazzled boy neatly arranged in a suit. The end of his golden chain was like a phantom limb weighing down his chest with guilt. He caressed the simmering medallion It was heavy, consumed of success, overwhelming Winston with the guilty burden. He brushed a hand through his sweaty curls, plastered onto his forehead, wrinkled with years of stress.

“You’re late again Winston, make me a chai latte, skim milk and two sugars and deliver It to block 37! Pronto!” Reynolds glared at him with slate grey beady eyes.

Car horns honked furiously, pushing and heaving the heavy traffic like viscous honey. Passers by chugged coffee, gulping like savage animals. Women in tight dresses clicked their heels onto the asphalt. Their hair was tucked perfectly in symmetrical buns and the men had theirs gelled in sharp jarring angles.

A cacophony of posters polluted the streets in herds and the banners decorated the streets, dripping with green.

“Vote green. Save our world. Vote for a brighter future and vote Forest!” The jungle of clones protested in front of the voting centre in a rhythmic march.

A pamphlet slid into Winston’s hands and once a whimper, the grin stretched across the page preserving the insults he had once tortured the boy with. Buildings towered menacingly above him, puncturing the happiness from the clouds and absorbing the sun’s silver rays. They leered like spectators with ravenous hunger as early morning commuters trudged behind robotically. Their faces were encrusted with decade-old grime and suffocated between a thick blanketing haze. Winston threw the pamphlet in the recycling bin. His stocky frame blended with the harsh lines of the angry city.

Winston watched him enter the centre. Bitter bile clogged his throat.

Everything was muted, the auditorium silencing in his presence. He approached a microphone and a confident voice escaped his thin lips, crushing Winston’s dreams with every heavy step he took.

And in an instant as if seeing it all again, Winston’s mind raced back to a time in where he was nineteen. The same brown hair in a modern comb over stared back at him. A line was shaved in his part. His suit was handsomely pressed. The boy next to him also had his shirt ironed, and the same line was shaved in his part. And despite the artificial smile attached to his face, a quiver escaped his small lips. And Winston drowned. He drowned in the sea of clones surrounding him.

But a lanky boy stood out amidst the sea of sheep.

Winston looked at him, his chest constricted, his forehead damp.

The tattered jeans and outdated shag reflected in the shiny metal made it ridiculous for anyone to believe he was even associated with his man in a different time.

Clutching his sides Winston gulped for breath after sprinting out of the centre.

He tried to piece together how this could be, how such a…a loser could become something better than him. Now he didn’t have anything but the plain shards of its memory stabbing at him like a dull knife. He couldn’t recall why he had become the loser he had been trying to avoid his entire life.

The crowd of green drones followed George like unfed pets begging for attention. George’s voice droned on in the background, a slight whisper caressing him.

“Good morning my loyal supporters,

I am George Forest and, electing me will lead to drastic change in your city. I’d like to build a green wall along Sydney tower and let us Sydney-siders salvage our dying nation. I will make your health a priority, and monitor air quality readings daily.”

“We want green!” Cheered the supporters.

George rushed out of the centre heedless of the clutching hands and questioning voices, parting the sea of heads with his outstretched arms.

Hot brown liquid splashed onto Winston’s arm leaving a scalding reminder of George’s burning eyes as he was pushed over by the buzzing crowd.

“Get off me,” George sneered and the once perfect smile scowled into a bitter grimace. “And by the way don’t forget to vote for me of course,” he chuckled sardonically.

The giant billboard mocked him, and like a vicious cancer burgeoning through the city its gaze burnt Winston’s pride. But what was the use of this pride if it was going to isolate him?

Winston refused to keep such a demeaning object. He snapped the medal in his fingers and shards of yellow plastic scattered surrounding him.

Outside the voting centre red poppies emerged through the soil and their deep, rich-red petals coloured the grass.

George left as Winston observed a single green note escape his briefcase, gently landing on the tallest poppy.

Comments
- The first section, it is a little unclear what is happening. I think that's the intention, but even then, it's a bit too disorienting for my taste. Perhaps some description of the setting could help there?
- Some really cool imagery and word choice as the creative progresses, setting a really nice tone to the story. You have a cool writing style!
- Further, you do a really good job of portraying the emotional state of your protagonist. I'm inside their head, which is awesome! However, I'm still a TAD confused as to the exact specifics of what is happening by the middle. I get it, but I feel like I'm working a tad too hard to get it if you catch me. Be sure your plot is clear!
- The speech given by George is a little forced. It's not how a political speech would read, not a huge deal
- Not 100% sure of the significance of the Poppy motif

I think you are a really fantastic writer; I'll start with that. You've got some cool use of language here and you create a fantastic tone really quickly. You've got your style and it works really well for you! Really my biggest comment is that I'm not really getting a Discovery concept out of this. Be sure that when you head in tomorrow, you are actively thinking, "What do I want to say about Discovery?" That will inevitably get you thinking about it throughout, and that will translate into the concept being more obvious in your story! I know it is there now, but I'm looking for it to shine through a bit more :)

Don't be!! I think this is really great, if you just really keep Discovery in your head when you write it tomorrow, then the concept will naturally be stronger, which is the only really big suggestion I'd make. You will smash it! Good luck :)

The discovery is a rediscovery of an old rival friend and the persona doesn't want to deal with them as they were envious of their success. Then they discover that success is not measurable by their outward appearance but about their personality. The poppies symbolise egalitarianism or "tall poppy syndrome" where society doesn't want anyone to rise above the rest and become successful :/ hopefully my story isn't too confusing. Thank you so much for the help :P