WTH with the balck line one =.=* It looks like sometihng hot burned the paper like a grill or something (no offence to the artist, I'm sure they have a lot more artistic talent than myself)
The Menzies one (4th i presume) does look a lot like the VTAC ones, nothing wrong with that necessarily, even the current 2009 diaries has the same "feel" to it (inside the actual diary)
The 3rd one I don't get it. It seems to appeal more to girls/women? A bird...key...sky? Is it like dream large or sometihng? Or was that Melb. Uni's slogan =.=* HOWEVER, the clouds look realistic, and the designer is artistic.
The face of Sir John Monash I presume in the text is wow,wow, wow. I would vote for that one! It looks good, and its smart how the text is about University courses like Medicine, Engineering etc.
Art is art, and I guess all of them are good in their own way except the 1st one, WTH man.