for VCAA 2008, question 7d SA,
it goes what fragment must have been lost from the molecular ion to account for the high peak at m/z 45?
I wrote H+ atom,
the assessor's report wrote H or H atom. and then they went on to say C2H5O+ was also accepted. The most common answer was H+. Does that mean H+ is wrong or right?
http://www.vcaa.vic.edu.au/vce/studies/chemistry/assessreports/2008/chemistry_assessrep_june08.pdf
Nope, H+ is incorrect.
The reason why is because when a fragment is lost, it is an atom that has been lost, not an ion.
So if I ionise propane for arguments sake, and a C2H5+ fragment occurs, it means that CH3 has been lost, not CH3+.
Think of it this way, if we have a covalent bond between C-C which indicates that is sharing two electrons. I get an axe and put it through that bond, one of the carbons will keep the two electrons, and the other will be left 1 short. Hence, the fragment is the one that has lost an electron and thus has a positive charge, and the fragment lost has gained an electron and is satisfied.
DISCLAIMER: This is not actually how it works, but it's a simplified way of thinking about it.
The reason why they accepted C2H5+ is because they used the word "fragment" - this usually denotes the part of the molecule that has the + charge.