Can i just ask a few questions.
Person A and B wants to transfer to commerce from a science degree.
Person A: Has met the indicative ATAR but did not meet the GPA standard.
Person B: Has met the indicative GPA but did not meet the indicative ATAR.
Would they both be considered for the place? what are the chances that they will get rejected?
Thanks
If both people have only done a semester of uni (that is, their first year), then Person A will most likely be admitted into B.Com since they haven't completed a full year of tertiary studies and their ATAR holds a higher weighting. Person B is in a little bit of a complicated situation since they haven't met the 2011 Clearly-In ATAR but has a good GPA. But depending on how high the GPA is, they might still be in consideration because tertiary studies are a better indicator of success in uni as indicated by staff from the undergraduate faculty of commerce.
However, if both people have done at least a full-time year of tertiary studies, then Person B would most likely have the upper hand because the tertiary results are more recent and like I said before, a better indicator of their success.
In any case, my explanation is just based on the theory. In practice, I would strongly recommend both Person A & Person B to apply because based on supply and demand, both of these people could make a successful mid year transfer.