I chose the second one and glad i did so.
Structure of my writting
General Intro.
Paragraph 1. Totally about Nick (Slight touch on his mothers words about how you remember someone how they lived, not died)
Paragraph 2. Meryl, also mentioning that Nick has a big impact on her.
Paragraph 3. Andy and Anna. Also mentioned that Anna's outlook on life changes, but debatable whether it is to a positive or negative view)
Paragraph 4. Julia and the Train driver (They are able to move on with life after apologizing to each other, passing the stage of grief, also shown through the background song the Arlenes - Lonely wont leave me alone [pleased i managed to fit this in somewhere])
Conclusion. Summed up that everyone changes even if they weren't directly affected by the event to a positive or negative.
Ended up being 4 or so pages.
And Jsimmo, really impressive plan you wrote there. Hope you get the an awesome mark, sounds like you deserve it =]