Everyone is suggesting you keep to English because Lit is actually more challenging, especially for somebody jumping straight into it at 3/4 level. Given that most of the people who choose it in the first place are stronger English students, you'll have a harder time getting a high study score in it. The "two passages to analyse" is also deceptive; the Argued Readings you'll be writing in the Lit exam are in a league of their own difficulty-wise, and whereas high marks in English can be obtained with 800-1000 words, with Lit you really need 1000+.
The only reason Lit would be easier is if you have a very dense, eloquent writing style (which is what Lit examiners prefer) - in English the markers want clarity rather than flamboyancy.
well i did unit one last year as i said before, so it's not jumping straight in so much.
oh really 1000+ words!? why does it say 400~1000 on the VCAA site? i'd be surprised if over 1000 words is needed to do well if you do say 600~800 and it's pretty good. i'm not aiming for mid 40's or anything, that's definitely not possible. even getting high 30's i'd be ecstatic with!!
hmm i'm sure it would be difficult, but i will find english equally as difficult (imo).. i also am really bad at essay structure, as in i get marks deducted for poor topic sentences and introduction and so on, and don't do too bad on the actual content. so i'd enjoy doing lit for the more content focus rather than structure..
it just comes down to what's more interesting, so i'd prefer to do literature...
this is why i want to do EL as well, as it's different to english and even if i'm doing poor at normal english/lit then i can always just try hard at EL to use that instead....