Login

Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.

July 22, 2025, 09:57:48 pm

Author Topic: Free AOS Creative Writing Marking!  (Read 352620 times)

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

teebolt

  • Fresh Poster
  • *
  • Posts: 2
Re: Free AOS Creative Writing Marking!
« Reply #135 on: July 17, 2016, 08:10:07 pm »
Hi, I feel that my story can get very wordy in some areas and wish for some help in rewording it or just removing those particular unnecessary parts.

Nostalgia

Spoiler
My face is a string of worries and folds, bearing more lines than the roadmaps I have crossed mellowed by time. Long gone are the days of my youth, of bleary-eyed optimism and of dewy, porcelain skin. Today I am sixty-four, tomorrow I will be sixty-five. Tick. I take a sip of my earl grey tea, its familiar aroma reminding me of my days spent reflecting on life—which, to be quite frank, is as listless as a balloon whose air has been let out. In life I’ve come to realise things that have come with being a sixty-four-almost-sixty-five-year-old. No doubt some of my jaundiced views come with old age.

This year, for my birthday, I will not be celebrating anything. Tick. No emails, no letters and certainly no phone calls. My three children used to visit me on the eve of my Birthday bearing gifts with sentiment, enveloping me with love and celebratory meals. Not this year. Not for the last ten years. They’re too busy for their mother they say.

Tick. I rummage through a mahogany chest, with too many memories to digress, carved with concentric circles with a flower at its centre, an indication of unity and love. There are papers which have yellowed with age; old Polaroid films of my family during our holidays; and oddities that hold profound meaning to me. My fingers nostalgically trace a brazenly torn image of a quaint town in Provence, set against the backdrop of azure skies and milky clouds. Even the ground is alluring, resembling blooming roots of a newly grown tree, and the skies are speckled with tiny kites flown by children. I remember admiring the divinity of the sky and its heavenly temperament. These moments disappear the way a dream leaves a memory, and I’m left disoriented, lost in a nostalgic limbo bereft of such moments. I had thought to myself so many years ago, ‘why would anyone want to live in the city after seeing this?’ Tick. It seemed that I soon would.

My fingers stumble upon a letter that read, “We are happy to inform you of your success in gaining a place at Langman & Brothers Pty Ltd.”  Tick. I bitterly recall the day I received the letter, it was finally a testament to the backbreaking hours and headaches – including studying of five years of law school—which, no doubt has contributed to my leathery, aged skin. My celebratory thoughts were short-lived, with my dream job within such close proximity my mind went to finding an apartment in the city. And for many years thereafter my life seduced by the naive thought was a surreal, frantic whirl – work, home, sleep, work. Extraneous nightlights, sleeplessness and sleeping at the firm. Tick. Tick. I had indulged in the dreamy notion that I could balance a social life and family life, that I could have the best of both worlds. I had become another dot in the city’s undignified impressionist painting of the perpetually intertwined forces of sense and nonsense.

I’m viscerally drawn to the corner of an image at the bottom of the stack of papers. It’s framed with purple glitter and bejewelled corners. I don’t remember the image...I’m not in it. My memory’s at fault, only minutely succumbing to the intense coercion of my hazy brain, flashing instances of what could be recovered. I strain my shrivelled eyes to see my youngest daughter in a Tinkerbell costume posing playfully on my husband’s shoulders. I wrack my brain yet again, trying to think through the murky waters of my memory to pin-point this moment. Oh. I remember now. It was my daughter’s first dance performance and I hadn’t attended because I was stuck on a lawsuit with a large firm. Tick. Tick. My mind becomes numb with disbelief and regret, my blood cementing. I’m rigid—pitted in my spot.

So really, I shouldn’t be all too horrified that my children haven’t visited me on my birthday for the past decade.  I instilled in them a hardboiled approach to work, so what would make them exempt from my indoctrination? Or rather, what would make them want to live like me? Perhaps I am at an age where self-honesty is tough, or perhaps it’s merely symptomatic of the fact that I still haven’t lived enough to put things in perspective.

A shiver runs through my body, the crisp night’s air caressing my leathery skin. My attention shifts to my watch and I realise it’s only moments from my birthday. Tick. Tick. TICK. TICK. My whole life I’ve been fixated on time and achieving my goals. Finally, the weight of my regret reins in on me, almost avalanching me. I’m wracked with the suffocating guilt of trying to perpetually move forward, not realising that I was leaving my children behind. The dance performances, the musicals, the graduations. Maybe we should spend less time trying to make something of ourselves, and more time on things that matter. I wouldn’t be here alone right now, stubbornly counting down the moments to my birthday if I didn’t worry about the TICK TICK TICK that unconsciously runs through my mind with the persistence of a pendulum rocking side to side. Maybe time doesn’t exist and we are passengers of this moment.
Tick. “Happy birthday to me”, I say dryly.

I hear the sound of my phone vibrating at my bedside table. I breathe heavily and pick up the call, “Hello?”

“Mum?” a silence ensues before she continues, “Can we talk?”

No more counting the ticks, and more time counting the moments.

Moderator Action: Put story in spoiler for tidiness.
« Last Edit: July 17, 2016, 08:19:25 pm by jamonwindeyer »

jamonwindeyer

  • Honorary Moderator
  • Great Wonder of ATAR Notes
  • *******
  • Posts: 10149
  • The lurker from the north.
Re: Free AOS Creative Writing Marking!
« Reply #136 on: July 17, 2016, 08:22:22 pm »
Hi, I feel that my story can get very wordy in some areas and wish for some help in rewording it or just removing those particular unnecessary parts.

Hey there tee bolt! Welcome to the forums!!  ;D

Thanks for posting your creative. Unfortunately, we require that every user has 5 ATAR Notes posts for every essay/creative they'd like marked. So 1 creative needs 5 posts, 5 creatives need 25 posts, etc.This is to ensure that the service remains accessible and attainable for active members of the ATAR Notes community. Feel free to hang around the forums, ask some questions, say hey in our chit chat thread, and build up your post count! Then just pop back in and let us know when you meet the threshold. Thanks in advance!!  ;D
« Last Edit: July 26, 2016, 08:33:29 pm by jamonwindeyer »

elysepopplewell

  • HSC Lecturer
  • Honorary Moderator
  • ATAR Notes Legend
  • *******
  • Posts: 3236
  • "Hey little fighter, soon it will be brighter."
Re: Free AOS Creative Writing Marking!
« Reply #137 on: July 17, 2016, 10:38:57 pm »
Thank you so much!!  :D :D I love that you've been brutal to it!! I find creatives really annoying, and trying to fix it based on the 2349483 versions I've had everything gets chopped and changed so every version is basically starting from scratch  :-\
I'll take it, change it, bring it back  ;) Thankyou!!
P.S hahahaha don't worry, I'm missing it too

I'm glad you've taken this so well! There are some really awesome creatives posted on this thread, so you should definitely draw on the plots of some of them because I can guarantee looking at the plot of something will give you an idea - and it will probably be entirely different to the one you are reading, but something in it will trigger something in the back of your mind that will make you think "ahhh, yes!" Make sure you write down all of your ideas, because it could even be a combination of all of your stories that is the best idea!
« Last Edit: July 17, 2016, 11:12:07 pm by jamonwindeyer »
Not sure how to navigate around ATAR Notes? Check out this video!

elysepopplewell

  • HSC Lecturer
  • Honorary Moderator
  • ATAR Notes Legend
  • *******
  • Posts: 3236
  • "Hey little fighter, soon it will be brighter."
Re: Free AOS Creative Writing Marking!
« Reply #138 on: July 18, 2016, 05:12:29 pm »
Hey Elyse could you please check my discovery piece. I would really really appreciate it! Is there any where I can improve the plot or change a few things or where I could make the discovery more explicit?
Thanks in advance!

Hey there! I'm so sorry, I missed your work somehow! Back on it now :)

It's here in the spoiler, with comments from me in bold font throughout:
Spoiler
On the cab ride over to my village, my heart bounced almost as much as the tyres on the uneven roads.  As the cab maneuvered around the mounds of rubble, I directed my attention to a small makeshift hut where an old woman lay crouched, flies buzzing in a chaotic circle around her weary face.  Her face was the same colour and texture as the soil; dry, brown and weathered. Years of working, hunched over, in the rice paddy fields had stooped her posture
‘How much longer?,’ I asked the driver as he changed gears.
He mumbled something in Vietnamese but, because I had not spoken this language for a while, his words were foreign to me. I remained mute, and reflected on the past day. Only 24 hours ago I had discovered the harrowing news. The voicemail message was still ringing in my years. “Your mother has died. Return home, son”. Consider giving this its own line. I think it is strong enough that it stands alone.
As the cab neared a series of cocoon-like shelters, I began to experience a sense of déjà vu. The smell of burning wood wafted into the cab and, without warning, a serene sensation flowed through my body; the smell was the epitome of a childhood I had lost when I had left this place. A vision of my mother cradling me as she threw the wood into the fire sidled into my thoughts. I could see the sparks fly up in anger as the fresh wood disturbed the already disintegrated wood in the pile. This disruption mirrored my own instability at coming back

As I opened the door to my family home, the sight of a miniature shrine caught my attention. My mother’s warm eyes, so lifelike, greeted me. She was now trapped in a photo, no longer here to greet me physically, to greet me with a mother’s love. The earthy incense smoke circled around the photograph; I waved it away as I reached over and lifted the photo.
Guilt. The only two emotions that I had ever felt with regard to my mother were guilt and love. And now, the two intertwined, leaving me standing there, a twisted ball of pain.
‘Why do you have to leave?’ she had questioned, her brown eyes searching my immovable  expression for an answer.
‘Mama, you know I have to. Father was displeased and I have disgraced him…again. He will never forgive me for the comments I made in front of his friends”, I replied, my head bowed down in shame.
“ Your father was not disappointed in you”, she said, attempting to reassure me. You can say,
she attempted to reassure me" and cut out the "she said" if you like!
“He had just expected you to do what all our ancestors have done. The military is an honourable career choice but you have to follow your own path.’ She grabbed my hand, warming it in hers and leading me back to the fireplace.
My mother had not told me that day that she was seriously ill. All she had said was to discover ‘my path’, but had I known that that path was never to have met hers again, I would have stayed rooted to the spot, a solid oak tree refusing to bend
In Sydney, I discovered I'm just keeping track - this is your second use of "discovery." If there's a third, I suggest changing it for a synonym because you don't want to be too overt in forcing a discovery.a city where people were more focused on their 6 figure salaries than the number of runs they scored in the weekend game of cricket. I felt a sense of isolation. It wasn’t the fact that I couldn’t speak English because, at that time, I had known the basics.
My isolation stemmed from a place that did not resemble home. Even though I rented an apartment in Cabramatta, and even though many people looked like me, I felt like an imposter here. We could speak each other’s language but that is where it ended.
Saddened and alone, I went in search for furniture and items that I could use to turn my one bedroom unit into a replica of home in the village. I bought the same color furniture,  the same style of lamp and the same texture of bed sheets; I even used incense sticks to make it smell like home.
Skip a line between these two sections to show the flip in location :)
And now, standing here, home again, I wondered what I would say to my father.
Mesmerised by the photo of my mother, I had not heard my father come in but I did hear the shuffling of footsteps as he moved towards the fireplace to add more wood. My father was shorter than I had remembered him; had he shrunk with age or had I grown? His wide face was littered with sun spots, and the wrinkled lines across his forehead gave the impression of a hard life.
He said nothing to me.
I said nothing to him. I think these two short lines should be bundled together on their own. So drop a line before "He said nothing... " and skip another after "I said nothing...
I watched as he started to heat some soup and then lay two bowls and two spoons down on the small table next to the fire. He brought out two brown cushions from a cupboard next to the door and laid them on either side of the table. He looked up and motioned with his hand to sit.
I accepted.
We did not say a word to each other during the entire meal. The chicken broth was not as good as my mother’s. With each spoonful, I looked up at my father, wondering what he was thinking.  Finally, when he finished, he lay down his spoon, looked at me and said, ‘Welcome home.’ I smiled, unsure of the intent of the statement.
My father walked over to the same cupboard which had housed the cushions. After much noise, he pulled out a small, wooden chest and placed it in front of me. He then put on his anorak and left me alone.
Curious, I opened the chest. I picked up a wad of unstamped envelopes and then let them slip through my fingers as I realized realisedwhat they were. I chose one and started reading.I had not seen my father’s writing for fifteen years. Still, I knew the slant of his words, the sharply defined characters. I opened the first  letter, curiously and fearfully, unprepared for the overwhelming emotion that imploded from the simple act of reading.
For fifteen years, my father had been writing to me. For the first time in fifteen years, I began to cry.

I think you have some beautiful writing in here that has the potential to carry a great story. Unfortunately, I think the story is a little weak in the plot. Why did the father write and never send the letters? Does the mother's death have much to do with this? Can you tie the two together? Perhaps the mother told the father not to send the letters because she wanted you to live out your dream? I think making the connections between these small aspects will really lift your work and enhance the discovery. Because even though you missed home and tried to make your NSW house appear the same, your mum at home wanted you to discover a different world, and your father wanted to bridge the gap between the two worlds. What do you think?
Not sure how to navigate around ATAR Notes? Check out this video!

MarkThor

  • Forum Regular
  • **
  • Posts: 63
Re: Free AOS Creative Writing Marking!
« Reply #139 on: July 18, 2016, 08:56:11 pm »
Hi Elyse,
I was just wondering if you could please give me some feedback on my creative writing draft, and possible give it a rough mark out of 15.


The Path Ahead – Draft 1

My foot buckled as I stepped on another uneven cobblestone jutting out of the narrow lane. My gap year was ending in a few months, and I was no closer to finding who I really was, let alone having a connection with someone. We had been walking for sometime through the twisty, narrow alleyways that ran between the rows of low-ceiling slums that characterised outer Kathmandu. A heavy winter smog had settled over the city, blocking out the moonlight and making it hard to see more than a few metres in front of myself.

I looked over to the woman walking next to me who occasionally asked a random question in broken English. The sound of silence echoed through the sprawling maze of garbage littered pathways as both of our feet fell on the rough, uneven streets of the slums. My feet were heavy and clumsy on the broken cobblestone; occasionally stepping in pooled water that sent icy sparks rushing up my leg. The woman on the other hand had clearly walked these streets a thousand times before, stepping lightly and gracefully.

“Wh-where you g-go?

I continued trying to look through the smog-clouded path in front of me, trying to watch my step. “I’m just walking.”

“You n-not plan wh-where g-go?

“I haven’t known where I am going for years now.”

“Wh’what you mean?”

“Don’t worry, it’s just something you say when you’re not sure what your purpose in life is.” The words were a stark reminder that I still felt as isolated as ever; I had planned the gap-year to finally try and connect with someone. After everything that had happened over the past 11 months I wasn’t very hopeful, I doubted that anything would come from this gap year. “I’m actually just walking with no real aim in where I’m going. I’ll eventually end up somewhere.”

“You n-not know wh-where you g-go in life?

“Well it’s been a bit hard for me to figure out what to do with my life,” the answer flowed easily, almost without thought. I kept my concentration on the unclear path ahead, trying to see through the smog. “I’ve always felt so different to everyone else, not like in a special way, just in a outcast kind of way.”

“You thought about d-death?”

My head turned quickly, no longer thinking about the unsure path in front of me. The woman’s face was slightly creased, almost as if she actually intellectually understood the implications of what I had just said. I searched her dark brown eyes. There was a slight sparkle, possibly a reflection from the stronger moonlight making itself through the now slightly less dense smog, although it may have just been a trick of my spectacles. “Yes. I have.” Even though it felt clearer, as I turned my head back to face the slightly less dense smog my eyes still felt squinted, and the feeling of hopelessness still made my face taut.

“You f-feel still th-that way?”

“Well I still think about it, if that’s what you’re asking?”

“You have n-not r-realised wh-why you should k-keep living?”

“No.” I slipped on another slightly uneven cobblestone, the glasses on my face flying forward of my face. There was only a dark haze, and that familiar feeling of my throat constricting. My hands searched frantically to find the slim, aluminium sight allowing device. It was the only thing that gave me any idea of where I was heading.

“Y-you know th-that to f-feel a connection y-you must be h-half of the connection.”
 
The outline of her hand moved towards mine. I felt the smooth metal back in my hand. I stood up, choosing not having put my glasses back on. Her slim, slightly rough hand slid into mine, and she started to lead me forward.

“Stop I’ll fall.”

“N-no. Just tr-trust.”

We walked some way like this, my eyes slowly starting to adjust. When she finally stopped, my feet were on smooth ground, and my eyes could just make out the brighter moonlight. She turned and carefully placed the glasses back onto my head. “S-sometimes y-you just h-have to tr-trust.”

We were in the mountains surrounding the city, on a small high plateau, that felt much more open than the narrow streets from below. The moon was much brighter than before, and it shone on the colourful distinctive high-rises that burst through the smog of that lay on Kathmandu. There were deep reds, brown oranges, pale whites and the occasional splash of light blue and green buildings among them.

My lips were slightly parted; “It’s beautiful.” I knew there was something in the sound of my voice that hadn’t been there before.

Hope.

marynguyen18

  • Trendsetter
  • **
  • Posts: 123
  • School: Cerdon College
  • School Grad Year: 2016
Re: Free AOS Creative Writing Marking!
« Reply #140 on: July 18, 2016, 11:48:23 pm »
Hey Elyse, i was wondering if i could get some feedback on my creative writing piece its inspired by Alice In Wonderland I'm worried it may be too much like the original and there's no element of discover. Thank you in advanced.

Time moves ever so slowly now that you’re gone. Why do bad things happen to good people, it’s just not fair. You were gone within a blink of an eye, all Lauren could remember were those last words, “Take care of Cassie, I’m sorry if I made her feel like I was too much for her to handle. I’m so proud of the young women you and your sister have become.” As the casket slowly lowered into the ground, tears streamed down Lauren’s and Cassie’s faces. This was it, the last farewell to their beloved mother, the memories were to be treasured and be kept close to their hearts. It wasn’t supposed to end like this. How could this happen? Lauren had devoted most of her life taking care of her mother until she drew her last breath. Cassie on the other hand, struggled to understand what was wrong with her mother and didn’t cope with her death. Cassie and her mother weren’t as close as Lauren was but she was still affected by it. Later that evening Lauren and Cassie slowly started to pack up their mother’s possessions into three separate boxes: keep, donate and throw away.

“What does this even mean?” Cassie said, as all the words and diagrams that her mother drew didn’t seem to correlate with one other. There was an image of a small flute, next to a rabbit hole. Did this show Alice’s interest in music? As Cassie and Lauren were cleaning their mother’s room Cassie tripped over a pile of journals. Inside one of the journals was their mother’s recount all of her adventures that she had in Wonderland, her description of Wonderland was so detailed.

Lauren was staring out the window with dazed eyes, thinking about her mother and all of her mother’s struggles just before she passed away.

“I need to follow the white rabbit down the rabbit hole, to get to Wonderland”. Her daughter, Lauren was very concerned about her mother’s mentality as Wonderland doesn’t exist and is only a figment of Alice’s imagination. Lauren had a hard time trying to convince her mother that Wonderland didn’t exist. Alice kept tapping on the wooden table next to her bed and started singing, wanting to go back to Wonderland. The sun in Wonderland would always be shining and smiling upon the world filling the atmosphere with joy and happiness. However, Wonderland was only a figment of Alice’s imagination and as she got older, it slowly engulfed Alice’s perspective became a reality. Alice could not tell the differences between reality and imagination. She was lost in reality. When Lauren was busy making dinner, Alice wrote in her journal trying to leave clues on how to find Wonderland. Unfortunately, what she wrote made no sense whatsoever.

Lauren had no other choice but to be home-schooled in order to take care of her mother. At night her mother would always be talking in her sleep, and was easily distracted and entertained by a lava lamp moving up and down. Every night, they would have dinner as a family, Alice would be paranoid about the food she ate as she in Wonderland the cakes could make her grow abnormally tall whilst the drinks would make her shrink to the size of an ant.

What concerned poor Alice most was the colour red. It had made the situation with her mother worse as Alice would be in a constant hysteria and would occasionally cry out “Stop! Get away from me! She’s coming for me, off with my head, off with my head, oh I quite enjoy my head being attached to my body, don’t let her get me Lauren!”. Lauren could see that her mother’s paranoia was slowly eating her up, nothing made sense to Alice anymore only to get back to Wonderland.

Cassie flicked through the delicate pages of her mother’s journal, she was starting to regret never spending time with her mother. Alice drew a picture her cat, Dinah in the house she grew up in and with a caption saying how much she loved Dinah and missed her. Alice cared for Dinah as if Dinah was her child, Cassie had no idea that her mother loved animals and felt at home with them around. The photograph triggered so many memories that had been lost. The photograph was of Lauren, Cassie and Alice huddled by a camp fire, their dad must have been taking the pictures. All the memories had been stored in this simple, worn out journal. Her mother’s insanity had drove Cassie to her breaking point, how could she have allowed Lauren to care and worry about their mother to the extend that Lauren never had an opportunity to experience the world. As time ticked away slowly, Cassie started to understand what her mother had gone through. A talking caterpillar that was inhaling hookah smoke and offered the worst advice with such a rude, concise tone. Alice met a very sensitive mouse, along her adventures in Wonderland.

“Hey Lauren, what does it mean when mum says: that the white rabbit was a symbol of hope as he gave her a sense of adventure?”

“Well, Cassie I remember mum telling me that she wanted to follow the white rabbit and how unusual it was to see a white rabbit with a golden pocket watch that glistened in the sunlight, the adventure she mentions is her time she had in Wonderland and all the wonderful thing she had encountered, I know it may seem as a ridiculous concept but mum really did believe that Wonderland exists. The only thing we can do is accept it. As for the symbol of hope part maybe she wanted a place that only she knew about and by being in this hypothetical place she was happy.”

The pieces of puzzle did not match up as how was their mother was able to express herself in explicit details on paper but struggled to articulate words, as the only words that was audible from her mouth was “Follow the White Rabbit”. It seemed to be an impossible code to crack as the girls had no clue on what their mother was trying to tell them. As Cassie kept reading the journal there was an extending message of hope and about never giving up on your dreams. Piece by piece Cassie could see elements of her childhood being incorporating into the journal, about how her and Lauren would use to play on the swings singing nursery rhymes.

Cassie could feel the warmth increase in the room as she reached the last page of her mother’s journal. There was a complicated diagram in the bottom left hand corner that her mother drew of a small key that was hidden under a box that was identical to the one Cassie had in her room. Immediately, Cassie bolted into to her room to find the key that her mother had drawn hoping that it would allow her to know what her mother wanted her to do. To her surprise Cassie she had found the small key in the exact same place that her mother had drawn, the key turned out to open the box it was hidden under. As she carefully placed the key into the keyhole and turned it slowly to the left, until she heard a click. The box revealed a perfectly engraved golden pocket watch.

jamonwindeyer

  • Honorary Moderator
  • Great Wonder of ATAR Notes
  • *******
  • Posts: 10149
  • The lurker from the north.
Re: Free AOS Creative Writing Marking!
« Reply #141 on: July 19, 2016, 07:22:16 pm »
Hey Elyse, i was wondering if i could get some feedback on my creative writing piece its inspired by Alice In Wonderland I'm worried it may be too much like the original and there's no element of discover. Thank you in advanced.

Hey Mary!! Thanks for posting your creative!! Unfortunately we have an exchange policy in place for essay/creative feedback, you need 5 posts on ATAR Notes for everything you'd like marked. So 5 posts entitles you to one creative. 50 posts entitles you to 10 creatives. Etc, etc  ;D full rules on essay marking available here!

You are only a few posts off this mark, so feel free to hang around the forums a bit, ask questions, answer them, or have a chat in our HSC 2016 Discussion Thread! Then when you hit the 5 posts required, come back here and let us know! Thanks in advance  ;D

elysepopplewell

  • HSC Lecturer
  • Honorary Moderator
  • ATAR Notes Legend
  • *******
  • Posts: 3236
  • "Hey little fighter, soon it will be brighter."
Re: Free AOS Creative Writing Marking!
« Reply #142 on: July 19, 2016, 09:00:47 pm »
Hi Elyse,
I was just wondering if you could please give me some feedback on my creative writing draft, and possible give it a rough mark out of 15.
Of course!

Your work is in the spoiler here, with my comments in bold font:
Spoiler
The Path Ahead – Draft 1

My foot buckled as I stepped on another uneven cobblestone jutting out of the narrow lane. My gap year was ending in a few months, and I was no closer to finding who I really was, let alone having a connection with someone. We had been walking for sometime through the twisty, narrow alleyways that ran between the rows of low-ceiling slums that characterised outer Kathmandu. A heavy winter smog had settled over the city, blocking out the moonlight and making it hard to see more than a few metres in front of myself.

I looked over to the woman walking next to me who occasionally asked a random question in broken English. I think occasionally and random so close to each other, means that the words lose meaning. I think its best to cancel one out to leave the other at full strength :)The sound of silence echoed through the sprawling maze of garbage littered pathways as both of our feet fell on the rough, uneven streets of the slums. My feet were heavy and clumsy on the broken cobblestone; occasionally stepping in pooled water that sent icy sparks rushing up my leg. The woman on the other hand had clearly walked these streets a thousand times Being picky with word choice here - "a thousand" - I think this is a wasted opportunity to make a great simile, or improve the character's voice. A thousand is very colloquial, and this is in the first person so it's not flawed in that aspect, but I think you could be less sweeping with the comment and make it more meaningful for a marker.before, stepping lightly and gracefully.

“Wh-where you g-go?

I continued trying to look through the smog-clouded path in front of me, trying to watch my step. “I’m just walking.”

“You n-not plan wh-where g-go?

“I haven’t known where I am going for years now.”

“Wh’what you mean?”

“Don’t worry, it’s just something you say when you’re not sure what your purpose in life is.” The words were a stark reminder that I still felt as isolated as ever; I had planned the gap-year to finally try and connect with someone. After everything that had happened over the past 11 months I wasn’t very hopeful, I doubted that anything would come from this gap year. “I’m actually just walking with no real aim in where I’m going. I’ll eventually end up somewhere.”

“You n-not know wh-where you g-go in life?

“Well it’s been a bit hard for me to figure out what to do with my life,” the answer flowed easily, almost without thought. I kept my concentration on the unclear path ahead, trying to see through the smog. “I’ve always felt so different to everyone else, not like in a special way, just in a outcast kind of way.”

“You thought about d-death?” I love this. The broken English shows that this character doesn't beat around the bush, they don't have the language ability to do that - they just have to respond to it as they can.

My head turned quickly, no longer thinking about the unsure path in front of me. The woman’s face was slightly creased, almost as if she actually intellectually understood the implications of what I had just said. I searched her dark brown eyes. There was a slight sparkle, possibly a reflection from the stronger moonlight making itself through the now slightly less dense smog, although it may have just been a trick of my spectacles. “Yes. I have.” Even though it felt clearer, as I turned my head back to face the slightly less dense smog my eyes still felt squinted, and the feeling of hopelessness still made my face taut.

“You f-feel still th-that way?”

“Well I still think about it, if that’s what you’re asking?”

“You have n-not r-realised wh-why you should k-keep living?” I'm kind of wondering if they are still walking, or making eye contact. The dialogue here is great. Super simple but incredibly powerful. That's awesome! But, just to seal the deal on the connection, I want to know what's physically happening between the two.

“No.” I slipped on another slightly uneven cobblestone, the glasses on my face flying forward of my face. Nevermind! This bit tells me that walking is happening :)There was only a dark haze, and that familiar feeling of my throat constricting. My hands searched frantically to find the slim, aluminium sight allowing device. Not so sure about this description, I think there are so many great things in this scene to spend a description on, that "slim, aluminium sight allowing device" is wasted on a pair of glasses. It was the only thing that gave me any idea of where I was heading.

“Y-you know th-that to f-feel a connection y-you must be h-half of the connection.”
 
The outline of her hand moved towards mine. I felt the smooth metal back in my hand. I stood up, choosing not having put my glasses back on. Her slim, slightly rough hand slid into mine, and she started to lead me forward.

“Stop I’ll fall.” "Stop! I'll fall." seems better to me.

“N-no. Just tr-trust.”

We walked some way like this, my eyes slowly starting to adjust. When she finally stopped, my feet were on smooth ground, and my eyes could just make out the brighter moonlight. She turned and carefully placed the glasses back onto my head. “S-sometimes y-you just h-have to tr-trust.”

We were in the mountains surrounding the city, on a small high plateau, that felt much more open than the narrow streets from below. The moon was much brighter than before, and it shone on the colourful distinctive high-rises that burst through the smog of that lay on Kathmandu. There were deep reds, brown oranges, pale whites and the occasional splash of light blue and green buildings among them.

My lips were slightly parted; “It’s beautiful.” I knew there was something in the sound of my voice that hadn’t been there before.

Hope.

I love a lot of things about this story. I love that the relationship between the two characters can be perceived as romantic or just friendly, and both work wonderfully. I love the setting, you describe it so subtly at all the right times and your writing isn't trying too hard, it just sits perfectly. I think the discovery is there so strong. He discovered hope, he discovered how to find hope, he discovered that it's ok to trust.

I'm really wanting to know what the native language of the broken English speaker is? Are they a tour guide? Are they a tourist? Why are the two of them walking there? It definitely all works without this kind of identification, and perhaps you could imply it rather than state it. But, these are the questions I'm left over with. If you're going for the effect of leaving me wondering to ponder about the discovery, you've achieved it! If you'd rather go for the "wholesome, no questions left" approach to the story, then that's what you'd need to change.

This person makes a spiritual discovery, an emotional discovery, in some way a planned discovery, and all of it is intensely meaningful. That's several areas of the syllabus being ticked off which is wonderful! I think this is a band 6 work that deserves a 14 or 15. The reason I'm not saying 15 flat out is because I'm reserving that mark to see a stimulus integrated. But this is truly, wonderful. The only thing staying with me as awkward is the description of the glasses I pointed out earlier. You can get away with changing only one thing based on my advice, and if you do, please make it the description. It limits the wonder of your work with a mechanical description.

This is so magical. If you have any questions, please let me know! :)
Not sure how to navigate around ATAR Notes? Check out this video!

MarkThor

  • Forum Regular
  • **
  • Posts: 63
Re: Free AOS Creative Writing Marking!
« Reply #143 on: July 19, 2016, 09:20:15 pm »
Hi Elyse,
Thanks for the awesome advice, I'll definitely change that description of the glasses as well as some of the other stuff!

Spencerr

  • Forum Regular
  • **
  • Posts: 98
  • Things will turn out better than expected.
Re: Free AOS Creative Writing Marking!
« Reply #144 on: July 19, 2016, 09:46:00 pm »
Hey there! I'm so sorry, I missed your work somehow! Back on it now :)

It's here in the spoiler, with comments from me in bold font throughout:
Spoiler
On the cab ride over to my village, my heart bounced almost as much as the tyres on the uneven roads.  As the cab maneuvered around the mounds of rubble, I directed my attention to a small makeshift hut where an old woman lay crouched, flies buzzing in a chaotic circle around her weary face.  Her face was the same colour and texture as the soil; dry, brown and weathered. Years of working, hunched over, in the rice paddy fields had stooped her posture
‘How much longer?,’ I asked the driver as he changed gears.
He mumbled something in Vietnamese but, because I had not spoken this language for a while, his words were foreign to me. I remained mute, and reflected on the past day. Only 24 hours ago I had discovered the harrowing news. The voicemail message was still ringing in my years. “Your mother has died. Return home, son”. Consider giving this its own line. I think it is strong enough that it stands alone.
As the cab neared a series of cocoon-like shelters, I began to experience a sense of déjà vu. The smell of burning wood wafted into the cab and, without warning, a serene sensation flowed through my body; the smell was the epitome of a childhood I had lost when I had left this place. A vision of my mother cradling me as she threw the wood into the fire sidled into my thoughts. I could see the sparks fly up in anger as the fresh wood disturbed the already disintegrated wood in the pile. This disruption mirrored my own instability at coming back

As I opened the door to my family home, the sight of a miniature shrine caught my attention. My mother’s warm eyes, so lifelike, greeted me. She was now trapped in a photo, no longer here to greet me physically, to greet me with a mother’s love. The earthy incense smoke circled around the photograph; I waved it away as I reached over and lifted the photo.
Guilt. The only two emotions that I had ever felt with regard to my mother were guilt and love. And now, the two intertwined, leaving me standing there, a twisted ball of pain.
‘Why do you have to leave?’ she had questioned, her brown eyes searching my immovable  expression for an answer.
‘Mama, you know I have to. Father was displeased and I have disgraced him…again. He will never forgive me for the comments I made in front of his friends”, I replied, my head bowed down in shame.
“ Your father was not disappointed in you”, she said, attempting to reassure me. You can say,
she attempted to reassure me" and cut out the "she said" if you like!
“He had just expected you to do what all our ancestors have done. The military is an honourable career choice but you have to follow your own path.’ She grabbed my hand, warming it in hers and leading me back to the fireplace.
My mother had not told me that day that she was seriously ill. All she had said was to discover ‘my path’, but had I known that that path was never to have met hers again, I would have stayed rooted to the spot, a solid oak tree refusing to bend
In Sydney, I discovered I'm just keeping track - this is your second use of "discovery." If there's a third, I suggest changing it for a synonym because you don't want to be too overt in forcing a discovery.a city where people were more focused on their 6 figure salaries than the number of runs they scored in the weekend game of cricket. I felt a sense of isolation. It wasn’t the fact that I couldn’t speak English because, at that time, I had known the basics.
My isolation stemmed from a place that did not resemble home. Even though I rented an apartment in Cabramatta, and even though many people looked like me, I felt like an imposter here. We could speak each other’s language but that is where it ended.
Saddened and alone, I went in search for furniture and items that I could use to turn my one bedroom unit into a replica of home in the village. I bought the same color furniture,  the same style of lamp and the same texture of bed sheets; I even used incense sticks to make it smell like home.
Skip a line between these two sections to show the flip in location :)
And now, standing here, home again, I wondered what I would say to my father.
Mesmerised by the photo of my mother, I had not heard my father come in but I did hear the shuffling of footsteps as he moved towards the fireplace to add more wood. My father was shorter than I had remembered him; had he shrunk with age or had I grown? His wide face was littered with sun spots, and the wrinkled lines across his forehead gave the impression of a hard life.
He said nothing to me.
I said nothing to him. I think these two short lines should be bundled together on their own. So drop a line before "He said nothing... " and skip another after "I said nothing...
I watched as he started to heat some soup and then lay two bowls and two spoons down on the small table next to the fire. He brought out two brown cushions from a cupboard next to the door and laid them on either side of the table. He looked up and motioned with his hand to sit.
I accepted.
We did not say a word to each other during the entire meal. The chicken broth was not as good as my mother’s. With each spoonful, I looked up at my father, wondering what he was thinking.  Finally, when he finished, he lay down his spoon, looked at me and said, ‘Welcome home.’ I smiled, unsure of the intent of the statement.
My father walked over to the same cupboard which had housed the cushions. After much noise, he pulled out a small, wooden chest and placed it in front of me. He then put on his anorak and left me alone.
Curious, I opened the chest. I picked up a wad of unstamped envelopes and then let them slip through my fingers as I realized realisedwhat they were. I chose one and started reading.I had not seen my father’s writing for fifteen years. Still, I knew the slant of his words, the sharply defined characters. I opened the first  letter, curiously and fearfully, unprepared for the overwhelming emotion that imploded from the simple act of reading.
For fifteen years, my father had been writing to me. For the first time in fifteen years, I began to cry.

I think you have some beautiful writing in here that has the potential to carry a great story. Unfortunately, I think the story is a little weak in the plot. Why did the father write and never send the letters? Does the mother's death have much to do with this? Can you tie the two together? Perhaps the mother told the father not to send the letters because she wanted you to live out your dream? I think making the connections between these small aspects will really lift your work and enhance the discovery. Because even though you missed home and tried to make your NSW house appear the same, your mum at home wanted you to discover a different world, and your father wanted to bridge the gap between the two worlds. What do you think?

Thank you so much Elyse for marking this :). I'll try put in as much as the feed back as possible. You're a lifesaver!
1st in HSC Eco 2016

elysepopplewell

  • HSC Lecturer
  • Honorary Moderator
  • ATAR Notes Legend
  • *******
  • Posts: 3236
  • "Hey little fighter, soon it will be brighter."
Re: Free AOS Creative Writing Marking!
« Reply #145 on: July 19, 2016, 09:56:32 pm »
Thank you so much Elyse for marking this :). I'll try put in as much as the feed back as possible. You're a lifesaver!

Amazing! Check back any time, even if you just want to propose an idea rather than get an entire thing marked - always here! :)
Not sure how to navigate around ATAR Notes? Check out this video!

elysepopplewell

  • HSC Lecturer
  • Honorary Moderator
  • ATAR Notes Legend
  • *******
  • Posts: 3236
  • "Hey little fighter, soon it will be brighter."
Re: Free AOS Creative Writing Marking!
« Reply #146 on: July 19, 2016, 09:59:16 pm »
Hi Elyse,
Thanks for the awesome advice, I'll definitely change that description of the glasses as well as some of the other stuff!

I can't wait to see how you go! I love your work. Keep me posted! :)
Not sure how to navigate around ATAR Notes? Check out this video!

Essej

  • Forum Regular
  • **
  • Posts: 81
  • "Don't settle for good. Strive for great".
Re: Free AOS Creative Writing Marking!
« Reply #147 on: July 20, 2016, 09:01:01 am »
Hi Elyse!

This is my first time posting a creative script on the forums, i would really appreciate some feedback! Creative writing is continually a liability for me in exams, i can't seem to break out of the 12/15 low-band 5ish range  :'( . Originally I wrote a general, non-stimulus monologue for an in-class assessment (I promise there wasn't as much religious imagery in that one) and this is an adaptation of said monologue as a general creative to a past question.

Thanks in advance!

Spoiler
Question: To Discover is to be Enlightened.

Silence. As it always did, the boardroom seemed to eviscerate any trace of sound. The senseless chitter-chatter of workers was drowned out by this work of God, this safe haven. For  this temple of solace served as my beginning, my Genesis.

“Hiss” rears the snake’s ugly head.

I pinch myself until my forearm bleeds, hoping it is some frightful nightmare. My Eden, so long hidden under a facade of solitude and serenity, falls away from under my feet like some rusty iron boardwalk. My heart leaps into my throat as the realisation is driven home by the unceremonious “twang” of the heavenly Cloud’s bow.

Blinded by perspiration, my hand reaches for the handlebar of the elevator as it descends. My knuckles whiten as I tighten my grip, my hands erupting in sweat. Was I in a submarine? I was sinking, but suspected the elevator was not the sole perpetrator of the crime.

“You’re fired”. Never had a phrase been so perfectly apt. For the match had been lit; the blaze within my heart ignited. Faultlessly loyal, I was undeserving of such treatment. Like a photograph, I had been framed, left for the world to stroll past and ridicule at their leisure. Who was the catalyst for my exodus? Why me? The bottled-up rage seeks to escape my face any way possible; a bystander could easily discern the wretched demon within, begging to be freed by the fruits of temptation.

Breath escapes me in short gasps. Was the heat expanding? The metallic cage of transportation was surely overflowing with baptismal fires. Thrown amidst the volcanic wreckage of the unknown, I am Dante. But in this secluded exile, my line of sight envisions no paradiso. Is it an illusion? Or are the sauna like walls encroaching upon me?

Outside is no better. As quickly as the internal fire was kindled, it is doused by the unrelenting rain. A cold trickle of water slithers down my spine. My suit, much like my reputation, is unsalvageable.

My stomach churns as a sickening worm of doubt enters. Why did I choose this path? Was I not ready?

Ambition. Knowledge. Were they the seeds of wisdom, or the devil’s genesis?

The worm squirms and slithers through a crevice within the apple.

“Hiss” rears the snake’s ugly head.

The path ahead is foggy. I must never have left the elevator, for I am submerged under indescribable doubts. In a city of millions, of designated signs, pathways and maps, I am hopelessly lost.

The saturated delta of my arch-like thumb stumbles across the weakened spine of an untended book, haphazardly engulfed by my box of office-ly possessions. I begin to rub the accumulated dust between my thumb and its neighbouring index.

In an instant, darkness.

The subzero climate of the concrete jungle is replaced by the unforgiving purgatorio of the desert. The balmy wind forms an alliance with the coarse yellow sand, joined in their sole purpose of nibbling at my heels. I could almost taste the loneliness in the pure, unadulterated air. My arm extends, looking hopelessly for the faintest trace of divine intervention; that i may be able once more to open my eyes.

“Hiss” smirks the snake.

Was this not just a momentary respite? A pure fantasy? I live in the real world. A Mecca of torrential rain, rolling thunder and broken dreams. A locale wherein you will find no confessional to take flight from the inescapable clutches of desire and temptation.

Gone is the apple. Gone is the covenant. Gone is the flame.

I feel myself being disassembled, with the most valuable part taken away, and the remainder put up for auction to the highest bidder.

My wandering nails attempt to pluck the desert’s crystals as they encrust my eyelids. A blinding ray of light welcomes me back to the realm of vision. Evaporated is the impregnable torrent of water threatening to overwhelm each of my bodily extremities. Dessicated is the pentecostal flame.

A voice. Rich. Undulating.

I cannot discern each phrase from the next. My legs beg to differ, knees burning as my muscles protest in sheer agony.

The rain’s hell is the flame’s paradiso.

My hand clamps on His. Eden is left in our wake.

Damascus awaits.
Class of 2016
------------------------
English Advanced: 93
Legal Studies: 96
Economics: 93
Business Studies: 92
Studies of Religion (2 Unit): 93

2016 ATAR: 98.75

feeah

  • Adventurer
  • *
  • Posts: 14
Re: Free AOS Creative Writing Marking!
« Reply #148 on: July 20, 2016, 12:39:53 pm »
Hi Elyse, quick question: is this only for discovery, or can i post my creative writing for my prelim ext. english test (which focuses on gothicism)? i haven't finished writing it yet, but i would really appreciate feedback once i've done it :)

jamonwindeyer

  • Honorary Moderator
  • Great Wonder of ATAR Notes
  • *******
  • Posts: 10149
  • The lurker from the north.
Re: Free AOS Creative Writing Marking!
« Reply #149 on: July 20, 2016, 01:56:57 pm »
Hi Elyse, quick question: is this only for discovery, or can i post my creative writing for my prelim ext. english test (which focuses on gothicism)? i haven't finished writing it yet, but i would really appreciate feedback once i've done it :)

You can definitely post your creative writing here even if it isn't Discovery!! Just explain the themes you are focusing on when you post  ;D