Login

Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.

October 18, 2025, 10:34:23 am

Author Topic: Free AOS Creative Writing Marking!  (Read 369702 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

beau77bro

  • Forum Obsessive
  • ***
  • Posts: 342
Re: Free AOS Creative Writing Marking!
« Reply #675 on: July 13, 2017, 11:38:31 pm »
Hey so I've taken some advice from the atarnotes and i've tried to make this creative more abstract and a bit more intense. I feel like I've included a lot of points i could expand upon and include different motifs for different stimuli. I'm about to go through it with my teacher sister, so if you don't get to it soon that's ok i will post an improve (grammatically and making sense wise) version in a day or so.

Thank you - ps. mostly a dramatised non-fiction. but I'm super open to changing any part of it.

IM ADDING A REVISED VERSION - I'VE ADDED A DECENT BIT, BUT I HAVENT GOTTEN THE CHANCE TO EDIT IT PROPERLY. IF YOU HAVE ALREADY MARKED IT THAT'S FINE, MOST OF THE ADVICE WILL STILL APPLY. I WOULD REALLY APPRECIATE A SKIM OF THIS AND SOME BASIC FEEDBACK - my teacher said to start it in action, i didnt really know how to do that. i hope this is alright. if you havent marked it yet then yay. (sorry for caps i just wanted to make sure you guys saw this)

so yea - does it have okay discovery concepts? is it entertaining/interesting? how should i start it better, or is that fine? ANY FEEDBACK APPRECIATED

so yea you guys have already seen it and started (downloaded 6 times). but the revised version is very similar. i know you guys are smashed because trials are coming up. but maybe if its no hassle you could give some feedback on the beginning/first para?
« Last Edit: July 18, 2017, 05:29:02 pm by beau77bro »

claudiarosaliaa

  • Trailblazer
  • *
  • Posts: 46
Re: Free AOS Creative Writing Marking!
« Reply #676 on: July 15, 2017, 10:05:09 am »
I understand your concerns about the amount of dialogue and it can maybe be paired down but I think that markers don't like dialogue when it is used for the sake of it, when it has no meaning to the actual story. In your case, I think it works brilliantly. I think that the way you have actually described the dialogue eg. “I remember this one humid day, I was working near the furnace.” He pauses, his voice flat and absent. is so successful in giving your story an authentic voice, which is one of the hardest things to achieve in a creative. I think the touches of Italian (I am guessing) culture with the use of snippets of language also build upon this so my only suggestion would be to perhaps add a couple more references to your past culture but other than that it is very powerful and although moving to another country is not a new idea, the way you have written it, with the emphasis on dialogue, is refreshing.

Thank you! That really puts some of my stress at rest. Would you have any suggestions as to how to add more reference to culture?
Year 12 student, Class of 2017. I am currently taking Mathematics Extension 1, Mathematics Extension 2, English Advance, Legal Studies & Drama

dancing phalanges

  • Forum Leader
  • ****
  • Posts: 745
Re: Free AOS Creative Writing Marking!
« Reply #677 on: July 15, 2017, 12:13:59 pm »
Thank you! That really puts some of my stress at rest. Would you have any suggestions as to how to add more reference to culture?

Maybe, since you have already used the coffee as a sort of motif in your story, your father always looked forward to a comforting cup of coffee from some Italian brand made by your mother when he got home from work. I'm not sure just trying to think of something a bit different. Otherwise I always think just adding in somewhere, be it a flashback or even present day, a reference to the scent of Italian food or something like that can be so simple and yet add a distinct sense of place. Hope that helps!
HSC 2017 (ATAR 98.95) - English Advanced (94), English Extension 1 (48), Modern History (94), Studies of Religion 1 (48), Visual Arts (95), French Continuers (92)

Download our free discovery trial paper!

shamus.clarke

  • Trailblazer
  • *
  • Posts: 26
Re: Free AOS Creative Writing Marking!
« Reply #678 on: July 16, 2017, 04:16:48 pm »
Hi ATAR Notes,

I've been preparing for trials lately, but I'm feeling dubious about the quality of my writing piece. Would it be possible if you could take a look, please? I'm trying to get the highest mark I can, so any advice or constructive criticism at all would be really helpful. Thank you!


   
 

eliza.sargeant

  • Fresh Poster
  • *
  • Posts: 2
Re: Free AOS Creative Writing Marking!
« Reply #679 on: July 17, 2017, 05:33:18 pm »
Hey Elyse :)
I was wondering if you could help me with my creative...does it link to discovery enough??


Creative writing discovery
The loud ringing dragged him reluctantly from his deep sleep. Rolling over he silenced the annoying noise and headed towards the bathroom. As he flicked the light into the bathroom his blue almond shaped eyes were brighter than usual and they seemed to be speaking to him. “How fortunate you are! A wife. A house. A job. Gazing into them he thanked God for all that he had. Although each day brought its challenges, his life was full of happiness and satisfaction. Descending the stairs he straightened his navy suit jacket and headed towards the door. Tacking hold of his hat, he looked closely at the photograph on the mantelpiece. His wife holding a fishing rod and looking into his eyes. Her face full of life. Catching sight of the thick gold band on his left finger, the corners of his mouth formed a small smile making his eyes sparkle. 
But now that happiness was over.
Losing his wife so suddenly, so unexpectedly had made him age. The reality had set in but the thought of never seeing her was too hard, too painful. The days had passed to weeks and months, with people forgetting his sorrow. His loss. His heartache. She was a piece of gold in a desert place. A shaft of light in every soul. And now her absence hurt like a bullet. 
His worn out shoes mirrored his walk. A piece of now greying hair coiled around his ear and the little colour that he had left in his eyes was withdrawn. The light wind made his bones whine and ache as he quickened his pace in some attempt to keep warm. Gazing at his leather band watch he made a detour towards the bridge. Something about the serenity of the place made him feel content. Flowers blooming. Children playing. It was so picturesque. He moved closer to the railing, gazing further into the depths of the murky water. It was dark. Cold. And the longer he looked the more he could see of himself.
The silhouette of a stooped man. Little hair on his head. Wrinkles in his face. A face so unfamiliar.
From nowhere ripples began travelling to the edge of the pond in circular formations. What was it? What was watching him? Did he have company?
Strengthening his gaze into the water he saw a beautiful fish. Small. Alone. But happy. Its silvery, scaly body moved easily through the water hoping to find some satisfaction. But nothing.  Then it was gone.
Time passed and the ringing of the church bell brought him back to his senses. With one last look he turned. Feeling a sense of strength and encouragement from the fish he decided to neglect his trip to the post office and instead head home. Home to a new start. His head held high, hands by his side.
Through the bedroom window he saw a star. A single star twinkling like diamonds. It casted shadows on his wall making him feel like she was there. The lamplights shone on the rain washed street and the pale winter-white moon was a sphere through the tall pines in his garden.
He felt warm tears rolling down his face. Tears for all he had lost. Tears for the pain, the struggle, the grief. But tears for the strength he had just found. The rain came harder; it came to wash away his sadness. To cleanse his mind, his soul. Looking down onto the street he saw a young woman carrying a balloon to his neighbour’s house. It floated in the air. The words “I love you” were bright like a beacon in the sky. The storm clouds behind moved away into a distant world as he heard her words “I’m ok…I’m in heaven…I’ll see you one day soon”
Under his breath he muttered “she’s gone…I must move on. I can move on. I will move on.”

elysepopplewell

  • HSC Lecturer
  • Honorary Moderator
  • ATAR Notes Legend
  • *******
  • Posts: 3236
  • "Hey little fighter, soon it will be brighter."
Re: Free AOS Creative Writing Marking!
« Reply #680 on: July 18, 2017, 09:40:22 pm »
Hi ATAR Notes,

I've been preparing for trials lately, but I'm feeling dubious about the quality of my writing piece. Would it be possible if you could take a look, please? I'm trying to get the highest mark I can, so any advice or constructive criticism at all would be really helpful. Thank you!

Hey Elyse :)
I was wondering if you could help me with my creative...does it link to discovery enough??


Hey the two of you! Usually our post requirement is 15 for full marking, but during trials it's up to 25. That's not to say other students won't give you a few pointers if you ask for it, but for now you can use the forums for all kinds of other help to increase your post count in time for your trial exam! Let me know if I can help in any other way :)
Not sure how to navigate around ATAR Notes? Check out this video!

elysepopplewell

  • HSC Lecturer
  • Honorary Moderator
  • ATAR Notes Legend
  • *******
  • Posts: 3236
  • "Hey little fighter, soon it will be brighter."
Re: Free AOS Creative Writing Marking!
« Reply #681 on: July 18, 2017, 09:53:53 pm »
okay before I go further,

My most sincere apologies that you've all been waiting so long for feedback. It's been a really crazy time and staying on top of it clearly hasn't been achieved haha. AOS creatives are my priority at the moment and Jamon is taking some module essays. So powering through these as best as I can.

A reminder for anyone browsing this thread: the post requirement for a full piece is 25 during the trial period, up +10 from the usual. If you're looking for ways to increase your post count, we'd love for you to answer other student's questions or give feedback on sections of their essays or creatives to help each other out while we move through the marking.

A special shout out to Dancing Phalanges for assisting above.

And again, thank you again for your patience, everyone. I hope we haven't let you down here in the creatives!
Not sure how to navigate around ATAR Notes? Check out this video!

TheFreeMarketeer

  • Trendsetter
  • **
  • Posts: 103
Re: Free AOS Creative Writing Marking!
« Reply #682 on: July 18, 2017, 10:09:43 pm »
Hey Elyse :)
I was wondering if you could help me with my creative...does it link to discovery enough??


Creative writing discovery
The loud ringing dragged him reluctantly from his deep sleep. Rolling over he silenced the annoying noise and headed towards the bathroom. As he flicked the light into the bathroom his blue almond shaped eyes were brighter than usual and they seemed to be speaking to him. “How fortunate you are! A wife. A house. A job. Gazing into them he thanked God for all that he had. Although each day brought its challenges, his life was full of happiness and satisfaction. Descending the stairs he straightened his navy suit jacket and headed towards the door. Tacking hold of his hat, he looked closely at the photograph on the mantelpiece. His wife holding a fishing rod and looking into his eyes. Her face full of life. Catching sight of the thick gold band on his left finger, the corners of his mouth formed a small smile making his eyes sparkle. 
But now that happiness was over.
Losing his wife so suddenly, so unexpectedly had made him age. The reality had set in but the thought of never seeing her was too hard, too painful. The days had passed to weeks and months, with people forgetting his sorrow. His loss. His heartache. She was a piece of gold in a desert place. A shaft of light in every soul. And now her absence hurt like a bullet. 
His worn out shoes mirrored his walk. A piece of now greying hair coiled around his ear and the little colour that he had left in his eyes was withdrawn. The light wind made his bones whine and ache as he quickened his pace in some attempt to keep warm. Gazing at his leather band watch he made a detour towards the bridge. Something about the serenity of the place made him feel content. Flowers blooming. Children playing. It was so picturesque. He moved closer to the railing, gazing further into the depths of the murky water. It was dark. Cold. And the longer he looked the more he could see of himself.
The silhouette of a stooped man. Little hair on his head. Wrinkles in his face. A face so unfamiliar.
From nowhere ripples began travelling to the edge of the pond in circular formations. What was it? What was watching him? Did he have company?
Strengthening his gaze into the water he saw a beautiful fish. Small. Alone. But happy. Its silvery, scaly body moved easily through the water hoping to find some satisfaction. But nothing.  Then it was gone.
Time passed and the ringing of the church bell brought him back to his senses. With one last look he turned. Feeling a sense of strength and encouragement from the fish he decided to neglect his trip to the post office and instead head home. Home to a new start. His head held high, hands by his side.
Through the bedroom window he saw a star. A single star twinkling like diamonds. It casted shadows on his wall making him feel like she was there. The lamplights shone on the rain washed street and the pale winter-white moon was a sphere through the tall pines in his garden.
He felt warm tears rolling down his face. Tears for all he had lost. Tears for the pain, the struggle, the grief. But tears for the strength he had just found. The rain came harder; it came to wash away his sadness. To cleanse his mind, his soul. Looking down onto the street he saw a young woman carrying a balloon to his neighbour’s house. It floated in the air. The words “I love you” were bright like a beacon in the sky. The storm clouds behind moved away into a distant world as he heard her words “I’m ok…I’m in heaven…I’ll see you one day soon”
Under his breath he muttered “she’s gone…I must move on. I can move on. I will move on.”


Hey Eliza,

I'd like to help you out but I probably don't have the expertise that Elyse might, so this is just my two cents based on feedback I've received and pieces I've composed.

One thing I notice about your work is how unfortunate it is you miss all these opportunities to flesh out what really pains this guy. I get a sense of discovery from the piece but it was more a discovery, or a re-discovery, if you will, of what he has lost and can never retrieve. The ending, to me, came as a surprise and not in an unexpected discovery sort of way but rather in that it was cliché in how it happened. I guess in your protagonist's mindset, in such an emotionally distraught situation, anything can lead to a rash decision but I'd advise in re-thinking this.

Possibly have your discovery be one of poignancy - this guy discovers his life has been irreversibly changed, and it's beautiful how you've incorporated imagery about children but possibly use that as a medium or driving force for this idea. 'He saw the children playing. He saw in them what she always wanted but he also saw in them what she could never have. The sleepless, excited, frantic nights spent mulling the decision over and only ever discovering that the only thing she nurtured was a pestiferous disease'. That's very rushed but I hope you get the idea.

Also, alluding back to my first point - flesh out those metaphors and smilies to really create impactful imagery. 'She was a shaft of light in every soul and yet he came to find someone found the light too blinding and decided to patch up the soul's walls to keep it in the dark'. Once again, rushed, but I hope you get the idea.

The only problem with this approach, is a discovery may be lost, if not portrayed well. So, it really is an approach dependent on discerning use of language. I can understand why this plot appeals to you and if you do decide to continue, try and make it a little less forced. Don't have the fish serve as a conclusive catalyst in his life and in all honesty, I'd use something other than a fish - possibly one of the children? Maybe something else? But I'd personally only have this element to serve as an instigator of the possibility that there is hope. Maybe have him question whether it's possible to move on.

I rushed this advice a little - sorry! Anything else, just feel free to reply and I'll hopefully get back to you.

elysepopplewell

  • HSC Lecturer
  • Honorary Moderator
  • ATAR Notes Legend
  • *******
  • Posts: 3236
  • "Hey little fighter, soon it will be brighter."
Re: Free AOS Creative Writing Marking!
« Reply #683 on: July 18, 2017, 10:11:09 pm »
HELLO :))
would you guys mind marking my creative??? It's super rushed and it an obvious first draft because if you read through there are heaps of inconsistencies that I'll probably fix later xDD. But more specifically, could you guys give me pointers on how to improve the portrayal concepts  of discovery within my creative ??

Concepts of discovery that I want to show:
rediscovering something that has been lost - passion, inspiration and beauty
type of discovery: creative(his passion and talent as well as inspiration), spiritual(enlightening) and emotional (isolation), physical (sublimity of nature)
catalyst for change
discoveries can be far-reaching and transformative for the individual
reflection and character growth
his literal discovery: his attempt to capture and create the landscape on his canvas will not be fruitful from the inside

THANK YOU <3

I apologise four thousand times over for not getting this to you quicker. I'm so, so, sorry. Hopefully we haven't let you down too far in a time of need!! Onwards with the feedback:
Spoiler
CREATIVE DRAFT 1

Tick. Tock. Tick. Tock. Each jagged limb clawed its way relentlessly to its next position. The confining room stood proud in its entirety. Heaving himself from his wooden chair, he glanced at the calendar. ’September 1st’ it unforgivingly announced.I will say, I think this works - I feel tension, intensity, pressure. But, I've read at least 5 other "tick. tock. tick. tock." openings in this last year. I think it works here, personally, but I think it's best I let you know in case you want to take a run for originality!

The bedridden sun still buried in its cloak of anxiety cast a lone shadow on the floor, barely warming the faceless faces I'm not sure about this - I don't know what image I have? I kind of have faceless heads - like heads with a lump for a nose but no other features? I don't know this is the image you want to convey?which were smothered to a blur from time. The empty frames attempted to comfort his bare walls and salvage whatever kindling flame that still flickered in the remnants of his worn being. Several black and white photographs hung frozen in the unfruitful attempted to entrap the absent. Instead, tired and muted frames of grey and insipidity that lined the walls did most of the preservation, trying to compensate for the lost vibrance that he once had.
So far, really enjoying your writing style.

He missed everything. When he still had it. When he could still embrace it. Now, life was like this. Life was just .. life. He exhaled loudly. “What will it be today?” he thought to himself.

As if telepathic in its nature, the tarnished floor boards groaned in reassurance as he sank into the stool in front of the easel. Despite the cheapness of the wood, it still stood brilliantly. But it was almost succumbing to ruin, about to collapse from the heavy burden of imperfect and unsatisfactory canvas after canvas that encumbered it everyday.

He lethargically lifted the cup to his mouth anticipating the fresh steam of morning coffee as it tried to frighten the haunt of winter. He savoured it slowly, sip by sip, in attempt to preserve the seeping warmth it generously shared.

He sat down, facing the glass frame which prevailed I don't think this is a good use of this word, perhaps you want: showcased? the landscape beyond. A gust of wind rattles the glass barrier, unable to penetrate its haughty austere. Austere is an adjective, austerity is a noun, which I think is what you need here :) Outside a flock of birds crowds and nestles amongst the bare tree relinquishing the open air. How wondrous he pondered, captivated as each bird flitted about the boughs and tended to each other. Their powerful crimson headdress defied the ashen ambience of the chilly morning, riding the thermals above as if in a graceful dance. Beautiful imagery. Inside their fragile bodies, their hearts were beating, lungs were expanding and contracting, muscles tightening.

They paid him no attention. Love the isolation here. It kind of echoed a bit in my head.

Enticed anyways, he began to etch tendrils for each branch, engraving the rare moment onto his canvas. But the pencil disobeyed his mind, his fingers clutching its weak wooden frame anxiously as it quivered in his grasp. The curvature of their wise beaks had become the squabble of pigeons whilst their powerful wings appeared meagre upon the linen somehow. He concentrated upon the affinity of the birds but could not rid the aggravating transparency of the glass which still managed to impede his view. Scrapes and scratches, scrapes and scratches, the usual disappointing rhythm. 

A spray from the heavens suddenly came. Droplet by droplet grew into unrelenting pelts, dampening voluminous spreads of feathers. In a frenzied bid of farewell, the beating of wings disrupted the rhythmic tempo of the raindrops on his roof. Fallen leaves tumbled to defend its territory from the onslaught. Not quite sure what the imagery of this last sentence means? I can't really visualise what you want me to see. Each droplet alighted the coolness of wild vortices, falling, emptying, as it washed away everything his eyes laid upon. The innumerable little cascades frightened each bird as they alighted to find a haven, leaving him behind staring at the skeleton of the tree. The curtain of water had begun to obscure his view of the outside. I like "frightened"
 for the birds - it shows their vulnerability. It's a simple word but it works well.


But their departure didn’t sadden him, nor did his sadness cause their departure. He was used to things like this.

Rain enveloped, imprisoning the confines of his room. It was just him, and the rain on this melancholy morning.

He set down his pencil in the usual makeshift Heinz can which sat there pertinently, expectant. Instinctively, his body picked up the monotonous canvas as he had done day by day, contemplating whereabouts to lay it amongst the mass assemblage of many others. Now sinking into the leather sofa, he turned on the radio to fill the voids of silence, yet but* also to drown out the pelting rain as he tried to defiantly enlarge the asphyxiating walls, searching for accompaniment. (?) not sure haha….  haha I loved, because I read "not sure haha" in the narration voice in my head so I was like :/ :/ Maybe...searching for feeling? Touch? company? responses? sensory exposure?

*
*
*
*

The pummelling of tiny hands softened down in a final strum. He noticed because he could make out a slight muffled tingle. His ears perked in anticipation, his eyes darted towards the window, but a curtain of droplets still veiled. What was it?

The distant hum seduced his ear as he obliviously walked to the window. He laboriously pushed it open. Again, just a word choice thing that isn't giving me the clearest image. Laboriously makes it sound like a continued, extensive, task. But opening a door with a push might need some muscle, but it's not quite extensive. Startled, a cascade of sunlight rushed inside and pulled him outside in liberation. The wooden photo frames had now become apparent in vibrant shine of mahogany.
 
The buzz modulated into a chorus of low chimes, his heart palpitated in unison.

Against the stern boulder-like clouds which threatened to swallow the sky, dainty wisps of periwinkle greeted him through rifts the fog could not reach. His mouth agape, the grandeur of everything around him

The sound grew louder now, changing from an indistinct warble to a light trill.
 
The briskness of the wind made the branches waver to its melody as if inhaling and exhaling the perfumes of the fresh damp soil. He himself, hypnotised by its crisp enchantment, taking another cautious step onto the greenery.

He bent down to caress the rich tones of the earth below, darkened yet enriched bathed in the thrill of the radiance of the sun.

He could hear it properly now! A grandiose angelic chorus heralded in crescendo as a cascade of brilliant red swooped in, encircling above and around the birch. Its silvery poplars rose spangled with dewy glittering of gold and green in welcome.

Smiling, he planted his easel onto the evergreen grass and gripped his brush. He visualising an intense spectrum of hues upon the frosted blank. Meticulously, he carved strokes onto the awaiting linen.

A stroke of vermillion, a stroke of scarlet.

A stroke for each bird that returned.
Okay...the ending: I'M IN LOVE. I didn't fully grasp the significance of the birds until now, and they are such a potent yet innocent figure throughout, how beautiful. I do see the discoveries, so that's not where my advice sits. My advice focuses more on the imagery - just so that it can carry your discovery stronger and steadier. Okay, so with the imagery: we focus on the sights and the feels a lot. Mainly the sights. But I want to know about the temperature,
 and the smells. I want to know when something smells fresh and something smells stale, because this is another way of reflecting the discovery. I want to know when there's an unfamiliar smell and the nose is wrinkled, and maybe I want to taste the dryness of the air despite all of the rain outside. This is just extending on the imagery you have, because as beautiful as it is, I want another dimension. As a reader I'm thirsty for more, your imagination is brilliant it appears so I know you can meet the demand. Also about the imagery, there are times where the wording is a bit clumsy. You mentioned this is a draft so obviously this will happen - but I've identified a few areas where the imagery wasn't clear just to highlight them to you so you can go back and re-assess the word choices.

Overall, what a lovely piece. It was so easy to read this, my eyes glided through and there was a cinema of imagery in my head. A credit to you as a writer!


Not sure how to navigate around ATAR Notes? Check out this video!

elysepopplewell

  • HSC Lecturer
  • Honorary Moderator
  • ATAR Notes Legend
  • *******
  • Posts: 3236
  • "Hey little fighter, soon it will be brighter."
Re: Free AOS Creative Writing Marking!
« Reply #684 on: July 18, 2017, 10:13:33 pm »
Hey Eliza,

I'd like to help you out but I probably don't have the expertise that Elyse might, so this is just my two cents based on feedback I've received and pieces I've composed.

One thing I notice about your work is how unfortunate it is you miss all these opportunities to flesh out what really pains this guy. I get a sense of discovery from the piece but it was more a discovery, or a re-discovery, if you will, of what he has lost and can never retrieve. The ending, to me, came as a surprise and not in an unexpected discovery sort of way but rather in that it was cliché in how it happened. I guess in your protagonist's mindset, in such an emotionally distraught situation, anything can lead to a rash decision but I'd advise in re-thinking this.

Possibly have your discovery be one of poignancy - this guy discovers his life has been irreversibly changed, and it's beautiful how you've incorporated imagery about children but possibly use that as a medium or driving force for this idea. 'He saw the children playing. He saw in them what she always wanted but he also saw in them what she could never have. The sleepless, excited, frantic nights spent mulling the decision over and only ever discovering that the only thing she nurtured was a pestiferous disease'. That's very rushed but I hope you get the idea.

Also, alluding back to my first point - flesh out those metaphors and smilies to really create impactful imagery. 'She was a shaft of light in every soul and yet he came to find someone found the light too blinding and decided to patch up the soul's walls to keep it in the dark'. Once again, rushed, but I hope you get the idea.

The only problem with this approach, is a discovery may be lost, if not portrayed well. So, it really is an approach dependent on discerning use of language. I can understand why this plot appeals to you and if you do decide to continue, try and make it a little less forced. Don't have the fish serve as a conclusive catalyst in his life and in all honesty, I'd use something other than a fish - possibly one of the children? Maybe something else? But I'd personally only have this element to serve as an instigator of the possibility that there is hope. Maybe have him question whether it's possible to move on.

I rushed this advice a little - sorry! Anything else, just feel free to reply and I'll hopefully get back to you.

You're incredible! Thank you for helping out a new user before she's gotten her post count up. You're a true gem of ATAR Notes - I'm so smiley seeing what you've just done for another student :)
Not sure how to navigate around ATAR Notes? Check out this video!

TheFreeMarketeer

  • Trendsetter
  • **
  • Posts: 103
Re: Free AOS Creative Writing Marking!
« Reply #685 on: July 18, 2017, 10:23:25 pm »
Hi ATAR Notes,

I've been preparing for trials lately, but I'm feeling dubious about the quality of my writing piece. Would it be possible if you could take a look, please? I'm trying to get the highest mark I can, so any advice or constructive criticism at all would be really helpful. Thank you!


Hey Shamus,

As I've stated above, I'm no expert but I'll try my best.

Your writing's really nice and I enjoyed reading it but I really think a piece like this could sound very beautiful in a first-person omniscient narrator voice but this isn't a major problem and as trials approach, I don't know how keen you are to change it.

The allusion to the violin is one that is very interesting and has potential to create a greater understanding of this character but I feel it's mentioned and brushed away too quickly and my suggestion would be to supplant the flashback to the beach with another one of the violin, maybe flesh out what he felt, what he could've been.

My final concern, possibly one that I only share, but the link to discovery is outlined but definitely isn't prominent. I suppose if someone asked me what the thematic explorations of this story are, discovery wouldn't be one that jumps to mind. I get it, he discovers a long lost passion through remembrance, and in a way that is a re-discovery but maybe there's a better way to proliferate it. I think maybe my second point, with the violin flashbacks, is a good medium to achieve this.

All in all, it's very good. It's a piece that could definitely stand on its own as is, but I just feel, if you were to take on some of the things I discussed, it could be a more coherent piece that really propagates this notion of 'discovery' in any of its forms. (As I said, not an expert :)). Good luck bud.

shamus.clarke

  • Trailblazer
  • *
  • Posts: 26
Re: Free AOS Creative Writing Marking!
« Reply #686 on: July 18, 2017, 10:27:02 pm »
Hi Elyse, I have now updated my post count, I hope this helps. If not, please let me know if there's anything else I can do.

Thanks so much TheFreeMarketeer, this was a big help, I definitely trust your judgement.
Mod: Merged posts
« Last Edit: July 18, 2017, 10:44:00 pm by elysepopplewell »

elysepopplewell

  • HSC Lecturer
  • Honorary Moderator
  • ATAR Notes Legend
  • *******
  • Posts: 3236
  • "Hey little fighter, soon it will be brighter."
Re: Free AOS Creative Writing Marking!
« Reply #687 on: July 18, 2017, 10:43:09 pm »
This is kind of an embarrassing question, but would it be okay to post up a creative in the notes section? I haven't finished HSC yet (TT^TT), so I'm wondering if I should wait until afterwards to post it. It got 14/15 for mid course, though. (Literally the only criticism was too much dialogue...which wasn't much to go of off ;; )

I have another creative ready and sent to my teacher, and the criticisms I got were to do with length-wise (it's around 1100 words), what to do about italics (seriously, how do you replicate that effect in handwriting?), and some clarity issues in languages (because I tend to be very flowery in my language. Pros: I get into it, so I don't make too many cliches...usually; Cons: It's waaayyy too figurative at times.) Any suggestions on how to combat this? It might be easier to see with this new creative, so I'll attach it to the post.

(This counts as a submission, right? If that's the case, I think I have 4 left? I can't count, help.)

Hey there! I apologise for the delay...I'm so sorry! I love that you want to contribute to the notes section of the forum. That's so generous of you!
Spoiler
I’m stupid – that’s a fact.  Immediately I love this. My attention is grabbed. I'm so ready to see where this is going.

Every paper I hand in gets a 30% and a giant red “SEE ME” written at the very top. What makes it even better is when the person on my right accidently takes a peek and I can pretty much see the sneer behind that plastic smile, vomiting out phrases that’s supposed to make me feel better about myself.

Cut the crap, I want to scream, as if anyone in this hellhole believes in that. Your language is so raw, colloquial, I love it. So often students get caught up in being imaginative that the raw and real words we use each day get overlooked!

But I don’t. Because I’m already out the door and dragging myself to the confessional, ready to waste another hour doing nothing.

I’m enough of a hazard that the school counsellors are lucky if they don’t get to see my face every other weekday, when they could be sorting out other kids who actually want the help. It’s no secret that teachers have stopped trying all together; the only reason I’m still on their radar is because of my crappy schoolwork and even crappier attitude pretty much ticks off all the right boxes, and they’re obligated to search kids like me for buried trauma. The sarcastic tone is incredible.

Honestly, it’d be easier to explain if I did drugs or something. At least then I wouldn’t have to try to avoid the fact that even I don’t understand what’s going on. At least then I’d be written off as problem child instead of another child with problems. At least then they won’t try to hide their whispers when walking past poor Andrew Flynn, sending over the same looks of pity.

Seriously, why couldn’t they just kick me out like they did at my old school? It’ll be easier to list me off as another statistic and say–

“Andrew! Haven’t seen you in a while. How’ve you been?”

Christ.

On instinct I run – run away as far as I can before I manage to do a smart thing and bash into a wall.

Jesus, it’s like my head’s going to split open.

My hands are already wrapped around the sore point as I unleash a chain of curse words, half-conscious and curled up on the ground. The mishmash of voices tells me there’s a small crowd of passers-by, and I don’t even need to look up to see all the turned-up noses and strange glances. 

It takes a while for me to register that it’s Mr “Year Advisor” S whose shout practically gives me a concussion, and even more time to notice him transporting me to the side of the corridor. The world’s still a blur when a noisy bunch of juniors flock the hallways, and my throbbing head has half a mind to tell them all to shut up.

One hand against the wall, I stand myself up...for a moment, and then I trip on a crevice and plummet back down.

Thump.

Oh.

That was softer than expected.

Twisting my neck, I can see Mr S’s got me steady, the fuzzy feeling I get from the soft you-can-tell-me-anything-kind-of-teacher-beam signalling for me to kick something. Hard. I contemplate dive kicking him when he doesn’t choose the easy exit like everyone else, and takes me for a stroll instead, storytelling his classroom disasters like I’m some kid that needs entertaining.  What I love about this voice is although he's so sarcastic, he's incredibly smart. He's very perceptive to the kind of patterns teachers use to get students to engage

There’s a part of me that dies inside when I eventually find myself hanging onto every word, and I seriously wonder how Mr S feels about waking up in hospital.

Great. Now that’ll give this school an excuse to finally get rid of me.

Nearing a door, the room he chooses has dingy shades and smells of dust, and only gets worse when the sun blares in my eyes as Mr S opens the windows. I squint, hissing until I see the reflection from the glass plane – the image of a pale, skinny little boy with wide eyes. I make a fist.

Get out, I scream at him. Just get out, get OUT, GET–

Thud.

A force halts my projectile, a barricade wrapped around my wrists. Mr S doesn’t let go until the trembling dies down, and has me sit properly on a chair, leaving me to obliterate – poke – the desk out of spite. There’s a shuffling sound as the lights flicker on, and even with my eyes trying to burn holes to the ground I can tell that he’s pulled a chair up opposite me, just...waiting. Not leaving. Staying. Actually not–

I dare look up.

A steely gaze cuts right through my core.

Before I know it, the lodge in my throat comes loose.

I curse. Curse everything from the bullies way back when to the people now, still trying to crack me open even though I’m already broken several times over. Curse everything from school to the streets I live, and the only friend that’s managed to stick by long enough to say goodbye. Curse everything from my eyes that looks to destroy everything in my path, to not being able to open my mouth for even five seconds without preaching that the world doesn’t give a damn.

But most of all, curse the fact that after five years the professionals still have less than what Mr S manages to hack into in fifteen minutes, armed with only a smile and a few words.

Genuine, though, a quiet voice squeaks from the back of my mind, and even the hand-smack I deliver to the table doesn’t hurt as much as it should.

At this moment, I finally have a proper look at Mr S. He isn’t even pissed – just sitting there, nodding like he understands, taking it all in.

For the first time in my life I willingly take a crumpled paper from my bag and lay it out for a teacher, red-faced while I blurt question...after question...after question. We spend the rest of time gradually working through them...together, and anyone who bothers to take a peak just sees a normal student and teacher discussing normal school stuff.   

When the end of happy hour chimes, I’m held back for a moment, and Mr S looks to me like he wants something.

“We’re not leaving here without a smile,” and flashes to me his, daring me to disagree.

I’m betrayed by the twitch of a lip. This says so much about this student's attitude, I love it.

Mr S keeps his promise, sending me off with a wave and the same goofy grin. I manage to return it, heading to class feeling lighter than I’ve ever felt after an interrogation session.
   
I’m still stupid and that’s still a fact. But I’ve got an even stupider grin telling me I’ve still got a prayer.

You are an extremely talented writer. It almost feels like this is just something you knocked up on the side, just spewed some words on a page that managed to create an impeccable character in a serious discovery circumstance! There's definitely lots of discovery at work here - intellectual, emotional, spiritual...perspectives are changed, relationships are changed...it's really nice. It works in a lot of areas. This is a small and somewhat silly thing - but Mr S just doesn't do it for me. He's giving a teacher such a cool nickname despite being ready to kick him flat? I think maybe Mr Stephens or something like that works, and you could progress to Mr S later to show the change in perspective, but it's up to you. It just surprised me he was ready to award a nickname to a teacher that he was also resenting!

Overall - so difficult to fault this. It looks like you whipped this up so effortlessly (a credit to you!) so I get the impression you'll not have any problems with stimulus incorporation. For your sake - I hope this is right! :)
Not sure how to navigate around ATAR Notes? Check out this video!

elysepopplewell

  • HSC Lecturer
  • Honorary Moderator
  • ATAR Notes Legend
  • *******
  • Posts: 3236
  • "Hey little fighter, soon it will be brighter."
Re: Free AOS Creative Writing Marking!
« Reply #688 on: July 18, 2017, 10:44:38 pm »
Hi Elyse, I have now updated my post count, I hope this helps. If not, please let me know if there's anything else I can do.

Thanks so much TheFreeMarketeer, this was a big help, I definitely trust your judgement.
Mod: Merged posts


Have added you to the list! Doing my best to move through these quickly with enough thought as well. So shouldn't be too long. Thanks for doing that Shamus! :)
Not sure how to navigate around ATAR Notes? Check out this video!

dancing phalanges

  • Forum Leader
  • ****
  • Posts: 745
Re: Free AOS Creative Writing Marking!
« Reply #689 on: July 18, 2017, 11:05:07 pm »
Hey Elyse, if you could look over my creative that would be great! Used it for Belonging last year and got 15/15 and then this year for Discovery and got 11/15. The teacher marked everyone harshly, the whole english department basically hated him but anyway his only feedback and therefore it seemed only reason for taking 4 marks off was that it was "melodramatic." I would have disputed it but luckily since everyone else got marked badly I kept my 1 ranking. But, still if you could look and give your thoughts that would be great :)
Spoiler
The streets surrounding Darlinghurst Road, Kings Cross were encapsulated by the scent of thyme-filled turkey sizzling on aluminium foil and dazzling hues of green and red. Moderately sheltered, a mother laid motionless, in a silent embrace with her only daughter, Grace. A windswept sleeping bag, their only security from the sodden concrete beneath. In spite of the fear and squalor of her new life, Grace’s innocent exuberance shone brighter than any of the surrounding estates, splendidly adorned with ornamental lights. Samantha, however, was the image of a mother weathered by shame. Skin hidden behind layers of grime, and hair hung as a tangled mop over sunken eyes. Faded polaroid photos clutched between calloused fingers, her only remaining memory of Grace’s lost childhood, and of her father that Grace barely knew. Yet, Samantha had made a promise to her daughter – a promise to deliver her Christmas wish.
Samantha attempted not to dwell upon the past memories of a fulfilled Christmas. The precious nostalgias which to her, only seemed fair that all children would be able to experience. And now, Grace’s father was gone. Samantha used to love him. She used to cherish his company and speak of his name in softness. Yet, most nights she would fall asleep, clothed, on an unopened bed. Beaten and broken, she left.  Grace still remained too young, too naïve to understand the piercing terror in her mother’s eyes. Her father still loved her, but, he had to let her go.
“Where’s daddy?” she would inquisitively probe, with an infectious glow.
Samantha hesitated.
He was once treasured. Now a memory. A shadow lingering in the depths of Samantha’s mind. It was not as if she could simply say that he was an alcoholic. His life was one of more significance than the fateful addiction that it was suffocated by. Her mother did used to love him. She did used to cherish his company and speak of his name in softness. For the first time in her short life, Grace would celebrate Christmas away from the now distant comfort of being home. For the first time, she would wake up on Christmas Day and her father - would not be there.
“Mummy, my toes hurt” a stricken Grace would complain.
Seeing your own daughter in pain, the kind of pain no six-year-old should have to endure at such a young age eroded at Samantha’s raw heart. Grace and Samantha shared their vulnerabilities, interlocking their hearts as much as their fingers.
“I know…” she would quite simply respond.
“It will be better soon.”
Yet as Samantha gazed into Grace’s pale blue eyes, she sensed a more profound desire. For this, she could not simply say those same five words she usually would. Grace needed more.   

…………………………………………………………………………………………………..
Samantha peered out to Keltie Bay, flickering with scattered lights as faint laughter echoed in the distance. Where she had come from - the place that Grace called ‘home’ was consumed by an unnerving silence. Cold sweat glistened down Samantha’s furrowed brow. With hands clasped tightly, only alert to the sound of her throbbing heart - she was waiting. She shadowed her target. One of Potts Point’s finest Victorian Italianate estates, a harmony of classical grandeur and contemporary finesse, nestled in the quiet, tree-lined Rockwall Crescent. Standing in the centre of the ornate porcelain courtyard – a freshly potted magnolia little gem. From her sleeping bag emerged a rusted axe. She knew what she had to do.
………………………………………………………………………………………………….
Samantha lumbered up the footpath. The sleeping bag was no longer empty. Under the procession of yellow street lights her blood stained hands appeared almost a sickly blackish-gold. The sirens of police cars wailed in the distance. Yet, they were not for her. Still beaten, still broken, she fell. Without him, her strength had faded, slowly swept away by the wind. Grace was all she had.
…………………………………………………………………………………………………..
Grace woke to an unfamiliar welcome. Blinking, blurriness faded to a distorted mirage of green. It wasn’t perfect, edges frayed, insignificantly sized in stature. To Grace, none of this mattered. To put it simply, it fulfilled a Christmas wish. Grace stood in awe, she could not divert her eyes from the tree. A magnolia little gem, fashioned with hanging photographs. In the corner, stood her mother. A blood-soaked tourniquet slapped to her wrist, her worn hands no longer a constant reminder of what she once perceived as weakness. She had conquered her fears.
“I love you, mum!” Grace chirped.
“Your father…” she paused –
“He loves you too.”
The two stood together, mesmerised, not by the tree but by memories of Grace’s father. As they would most nights, they took refuge in their still windswept sleeping bag, pale polaroid photographs now grasped between Grace’s hardened hands, the only remaining memory of her childhood, of her father that she misses so dearly. So, every Christmas, Grace would decorate her little gem of hope. A sign that her father had also found his way home.   
HSC 2017 (ATAR 98.95) - English Advanced (94), English Extension 1 (48), Modern History (94), Studies of Religion 1 (48), Visual Arts (95), French Continuers (92)

Download our free discovery trial paper!