It's only two years into discovery, but we really haven't seen this angle on an essay question for AOS in it's recent history. I do think that when you stripped it away, you had a lot of freedom to follow through with the essays you've practiced or planned, you just had to adjust the wording to bring the aspects of the composer's intentions and the text's reception to the forefront. I can definitely see how that would throw people in an exam, it's not a typical essay question pattern. But, what it was actually asking was not unreasonable.
As for the creative - I can imagine that some people would have really struggled to work with this, I know with my creative I would have had to take a quite unique approach to answering what it wanted. But nonetheless, I think this is a good exercise for adjusting the agility of your stories in prep for HSC!
I haven't yet seen the unseen texts - but the consensus seems to be it was tricky!
If you're done with Paper One: Grab something nice and greasy wholesome for lunch, and get back on the horse for tomorrow. Paper One is done - if you bombed out, you can resurrect your English mark tomorrow. Proactivity is key to exams in succession.
I'll be here to keep talking about the exam, so vent all you like!